, , ,

<<


 >>  ()

2 8

:

( , )

( , )

( ,

)

( , , ) ( , ) ( , ) ( , , ) ( , ) ( ) ( , ) ( , ) ( , ) ( , ) ( , , ) ( ) ( , , ) ( , ) ( , , ) ( , ) 9 ,,. :,,,., . -.., , , .

, :

, , , ,.., . 111 : , .

2 ,,. ;

,., ;

,,,,,,.,,, ;

.., 1.

,,.,, 2.,,,.

() ( ).,, (,, ),,.,,,., .

(,,, ).

:

.. . . . . , 1894. C. 30.

. ,

(., 2004).

11 (, 1 ),,, ( )?

2,, ,.,, ?

3 (. ).,, ?

, 4 (, ). ?

?,, ?

(,,, ).,,,,..,.,,,.

:

, ;

;

2 ,.

,, .,,,.

:.,.,,..

,.

13 ,, 1,,,,.. ,,,..,.,,, ,,,,.

, .

, , , 2 ,, , -. ( ),,., , , ,.. , .

,,,.,

,,,,, (,,..),, ?,,,,

.

: ,,., ( ),,, ? -,, ?

,, 2. - , -. ,, , .

, 15 .,, ,..,

,,,.

.,,,.,,,.

,,,..

,,, ,.

.,,,.

,.

,, ,.

,, ( ),.. ,,.

,,, ? ? ( ) ? ?

2 , , ,,,.

,,,,,.

. :

.

,, .

,, 4 .

? : ( ), ?

,.,., ,,, ( ) .

,.,,,, , ., ( ).,,,,. , ,,,,,. 17 , ,.

,. ,,,,.,,., .,, ,.

,,,. -. :, ;

,, ,,,.,., - - .

,,..

,,,,,., ,,,.,,.,.,, 2 ? , , -, ?

,. : ?, (,,, )? ?,, ?

,,,,.,,.,,,..,,, ? ?

,,.,,.,.

.,,,,,.

, ( ) ,.,,, -..

19 . ,,,,,.. (,, ).

,,,,,..

1,,..

, ;

,, 1960-.,.

,

.

2. [1999]. 2 ,., -,,.,,, . ( ), -,,,,, ,,.,, -,..

( ),.,,, :,., ,,,.

, :,.,

,,,,,.

:

,.,,, :. 21 , ,., -,. ,,, o,,,, .

, 3,,. ?

, a,.,, -.,,,,,,, ,.,, , ;

, ,, -, -.,,,,.

,,,, .,,.,. :

2 ,,.

,.,,,,,. ( ),,,. (,,,,, ), :

,., ,,

,.,, ;

:

., : 1,,.,,, :,,,.

4 ( ),.,,. ?, (V.),,,.

- ( . [ 2001: 584;

].

23 ), /..,,. 1988.

,,.,,.,,,...

..

..,,. ,, ,,.

: ?,,., ?

.

,,,.

.

-. 19771987. (., 2000),.,.,,,,, 2 ,., :,,.,, :

,.

. : -.., 2001.

. //. 1999. 2.. 4655.

,.

,. ?, ,,,, ?

,, .

,.,,. ,, , 25 ,.

,,,,.

,,,,,,, :,.

,.., , ,,,. [ 2003: 40].

,,,,..

,, (, ) [ 1978: 43].,,, -,. [ 1998: 31].,,, (),., (, )., , .

,, 2 (),, ,,.,, -, (.. /., ).

() ( ).,,,,...,.,,,,,,,,,, .,.

, , . -,, , -,,.

, 27 .,,,.,,, ,,, [ 1901: 229].

,,,,.

,, .,,,,,,. :,,,..

,,, -.,,,.,,,,,,,.,,,,..

.,,,,, 2 ,. ,,,..,,,.

:

,,.,,., :.

,, .,,, (,, ),,..,,.

,,.,, .

, ,..,.

:, , .

,,.,,.,.

29 , ,,..

.,,, /.

,,,., ,,,,.. (). ,, [ 2003: 29]..

,,,,.

. , :

.

,. , ,,, [ 1902: 5].

:

,,.,,, 2 .

.... :

, -..,.... [, 1998].,...,,,...

,,,, : .,,,,, [, 1998: 20]...,, [ ].

,.

,, ( ), , , .. 100,... ,. 70-,,,,.

31 , - ,, ii i..,,, -,

[ 1916: 576577].

,,,,,, .,,.,,.

- [ 1901: 230].,,.

, ( ).

,,,,.,,, ,,,.,,.

/,.

, ( ),., 2 ,,,, ( ).

,,, -, .,,,,,,,.

. //.., 1916.. 2.

. 455647.

.. //.

.., 1998.. 2833.

. XXI..., 2003.

..,.. :

//. 1998. 2.

. 1721.

.., 1902.

. //. 1901.. 15. 2.. 225237.

.. :, (.. , ) //. 2003.

2.. 2634.

.. //..., 1978.

33 3 (18561936),.

:,. - ;

...,,.,.,, -.

.,,.,.,,,.

. ,.

2 [Pietkiewicz 1928].

. : ,,, .,, ( 300).

Kultura duchowa Polesia Rzeczyckiego:

Materiay etnograficzne [Pietkiewicz 1938],., , ,

..,,,,,,,,.,,.

,. ( [ 1991]).

4.

,,.,..

:

,,.

.,.

,..

35 [.. 8.. 2002.. 315.

2002....

-.]. ,.,,.

, :

. , ,.. ,

..

: .

,, : ? ?,,,.. ,,,.,,,.

.,.

,.

,, . , , .., ,.

,,.,,.

, :

, ;

, 2 ;

, / .

( ) ( ),,,, , -.,,,,,

. - .

, ,.,,,,.

, ;

.,,,..,.,,, -.,,,. 37 , , ,,, [ 2004].

,. :

// :

,,.., 2004.. 246247.

...., 1991.

Pietkiewicz C. Kultura duchowa Polesia Rzeczyckiego: Materjay etnogra ficzne. Warszawa, 1938.

Pietkiewicz C. Polesie Rzeczyckie: Materiay etnograficzne. Cz. 1. Kultura materialna, z 291 rysunkami w tekcie // Prace Komisji etnogra ficznej Polskiej Akademji Umitnoci. Krakw, 1928. 7.

vs. :

,,,,, :

, 100... :,.

, , . . () ,, 2 . -, (,,, - ) ., :,.,.

,,., : ;

-,..

.

, 1.

1.,, (),,, -., :

, ,.

-, :,,.,,, -.

, (,,,,, ),. - (,, ).,, 39 .

,,,,,,,.

, ;

,,.

,..

( ).

,, ,,..

:

,.,,.,, : (, - )..

,, 1.

, , , , ( , , ). , .

2 2. ( ),. (, ),,,. ( ),.

, - ., .

, -.

,.,,,,.,, : -,.

,,, ,,,.

,.. ( ):, 30%.

, 70% 30%.,,, 40%. 41 , (,,,, ), .

, (, ),,., , , : , ;

, -;

, .. ,,,.

, ,,. ( ),, .

. ,.

.

,,, :.,,,.

3.,.

. ,, 2 ( ), -. ,.

-,,.

.,,,.,, ;

(610. ) -,,.,.

, - ( ),., ( !).

,.

4., .

, .

: ,. . -:

, ,, 43 .

(,, -)1,,,.

2.,,, (, ).

. 2.,.

, -,,.

1. -,,,, -.,, ( );

( ) ( ),.,,,.

, . , , , , .

: , , ( !) , . .

2 ,., :.

2.

2.1. ..

.

(, 100%), - ( )., ,,, -., -,,, :,,,, .

2.2. ., - ( )., ( ).,.,,,,.

3.

3.1. ( ).

- (,, ),. 45 . (, , ,, ..)., (

, ).

3.2. . ,,.,,,,. o,,. : ..., [ 1972: 84];

,

.

(, ?),.

4. ...

,,,,.

3.,,,.,,,.

2 1. .., (, ), :

,,,, ;

..;

.

- (, ) (,,,, ).,, - ( ).

, ( - ):

-,,.

,,,,.,.

.

2.., 47 .

,, :,,.,,,.,,.

, :, ?

,, :

,, :,..,,, ;

,,., ;

;

. ;

-,. : -,.

,,,. : - (dnan nyntannci ),,,, 2 .,,. ,,.

,,

. ,,.

,,,.

3.,,,,.

,,,,.

,.

4. ( ) (-)1., -,, -.. ( ). :

-, , .

, , , , . , , .

49 .. ,, .

, palmier ( ),. envoyer,,.., ( ).,,.,.

- ( ), ( ).

4.,,.

,,.

.. : ( ).., 1972. (...

.... 10.).

Native anthropologist:

,, - native anthropologist. ,, , , , 2 .., native anthropologist.

,,,, ( ) - (, ),, -,. native anthropologist -,. (,,,, ).

, native anthropologist,,., ,,.,.

:, ,,,.

,.,,,.,,, ( ),,.

.

51 , ,,,.,,,.

native anthro pologist,.,. , ?.,, ,.,,. : ,, . ,, , (),,. - -:

, (),, ?

,.., ?

,.,, /, /,, ?

, ? ?,,,,.

,,,, 2 .,,,.

19971998-.. 10,,. / . ,,,,.,.,, .

,,,,.,,.,,., 8,, : : 100, 200, 150, 150,.,., . :

!,, ?

, .

,,,.,,.

,,,.,, 53 ,,.

.,,,,,.

,,,.,., :,,,.,.,,,,,,,,.

,.,,,., -,, -,,.

1998., ,, 2003..

,,.,,, 10.,,,,.,,,.,,..

2 , :,.. ,,,.

native anthropologist,,,,, ,,,,,.

(traveling anthropologist),,, ?

,,,,,.

.

?

-,,,. ?, ? ( native anthropologists),,.,,,,.,,,,,.

55 ?,,. :.,.,.,.,..,,.

.,.,, :.

,,,,.,,.

,,,., .

, . ,, , , 2 ,., (,, ),,,,,.

,., -,,,,,.

, ?

,,.,,,,. (,, )., :,, ?,,..

,,,, ?,,,,..

( , 1974.) , , :

(,, ), (, ), (,, )., 57 ,, ...,, :,,.

,,. :

,,, ,...

,,..,,. :,. ?

, - ?,,,,,,.,,, , , ?,,,,.

, ?

, 1997.

, :. :,,,.

,, :,.,,.,,,.

,,.,,, ;

;

,,,,., 2 ,..

, :

() l1, () l2.

, (), ()..

, (). (),.,, ( l1),, ( l2).

., (),,.,.,,,, (.. ),,., (),..,,.

,,.

,...,,,.., ,.. 59 ,. ,,,,,.,,,,. ().

,, ( )..,..,, ( :,, ).

? ?

,,,,, ?

,,,,,.

,,.,,,,,,,.

,..

2 , 1.,.,.

,.,,.

2,,,,,,,,,.,. :,,,.,,,.,,. ., ( ) 61 ,,,, -., -,,,.

3,,,,., (,, ), - -.

( ), ( )., :

, ( ?),., - :.

:.

4,,,,,.

,,,, -..,.., (..

, ),,.,,,.

,, 2 ,.

,,.,,,.,,,,..,,., (, ),,,.

2004., 80 %,,.,., -,.,,.

?,. ,,., ().

,, 1 -,..

, 63 19601980-. . :,,. .,.,,,.

,,.,,.,. -,.

,, ;

,..

2,.,,.

, : ,,,,,, .

,,.

,,,,.

,,,..

,,,.

2 , 1960-.,, 1990-, ? ?, , :

.,.

3,.

- ..,,,.., A.M.,..,..,.

.

, : .

, ,,,,,,,,,,.

(Hirokazu Miyazaki) ,., - 65 ,, [Franklin 1997;

Good 1990]. [Verdery 1995: 654655]. [Hage 2003: 3].,,,,, [Appadurai 2004].

,.,,, ? [Crapanzano 2003: 20] ?

? [ : 14].

:, ? [ : 25;

.. Miyazaki 2004], , c

[Wagner 1981 [1975]: 2]1.,,,,,,.,,,,,.,,, , .

2 ,,,.

,,,,,,. (replicate), [Miyazaki 2004].,,.

, ,,.,,.,,.

-. (not-yet).,, ,,.,,.,.,,,..,. 67 1. ,,,,,,..

.,,..

.

,., , [Edey, Jevne 2003: 44].,, (hope-focused)., ,, [ : 46].,, [ : 46;

...]., [ :

47],.

,.,,, [ ] [ ].

,, [ ]. , , [Turner 2002:

83]. [ ] [ : 83], , , [. Miyazaki 2004;

Miyazaki, in press].

2 ,.

.,,,,,,, [Maurer 2002;

Strathern 2000], [Brenneis 1999], [Riles 2000], [Riles 2000], [Holmes, Markus 2004]. [.,, Holmes, Markus 2004;

Maurer 2002;

Miyazaki, Riles 2004;

Riles 2000, 2004].,,,.,, [. Miyazaki 2003, 2004].

,,,,. [.,, Harvey 2000;

Zournazi 2002].,,.

69 Appadurai A. The Capacity to Aspire: Culture and the Terms of Recogni tion // Culture and Public Action: A Cross-Disciplinary Dialogue on Development Policy / Ed. by V. Rao, M. Walton Stanford, 2004.

P. 5984.

Bloch E. The Principle of Hope / Trans. Plaice N., Plaice S., Knight P.

Cambridge (Mass.), 1986.

Brenneis D. New Lexicon, Old Language: Negotiating the Global at the National Science Foundation // Critical Anthropology Now:

Unexpected Contexts, Shifting Constituencies, Changing Agendas / Ed. by G.E. Marcus Santa Fe, 1999. P. 123146.

Crapanzano V. Reflections on Hope as a Category of Social and Psychological Analysis // Cultural Anthropology. 2003. Vol. 18.

No. 1. P. 332.

Edey W., Jevne R.F. Hope, Illness, and Counselling Practice: Making Hope Visible // Canadian Journal of Counselling. 2003. Vol. 37. No. 1.

P. 4451.

Franklin S. Embodied Progress: A Cultural Account of Assisted Conception.

L., 1997.

Good M.-J. Del Vecchio, Good B.J., Schaffer C., Lind S.E. American Oncology and the Discourse on Hope // Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry. 1990. Vol. 14. No 1. P. 5979.

Hage G. Against Paranoid Nationalism: Searching for Hope in a Shrinking Society. Annandale, NSW, 2003.

Holmes D.R., Marcus G.E. Cultures of Expertise and the Management of Globalization: Toward the Re-functioning of Ethnography // Global Assemblages: Technology, Politics and Ethics as Anthropological Problems / Ed. by A. Ong, S. Collier Malden. MA, 2004. P. 235252.

Harvey D. Spaces of Hope. Berkeley, 2000.

Maurer B. Anthropological and Accounting Knowledge in Islamic Banking and Finance: Rethinking Critical Accounts // Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute. 2002. Vol. 8 [new series]. No. 4. P. 645667.

Miyazaki H. The Temporalities of the Market // American Anthropologist.

2003. Vol. 105. No. [2]. P. 255265.

Miyazaki H. The Method of Hope: Anthropology, Philosophy and Fijian Knowledge. Stanford, 2004.

Miyazaki H. Documenting the Present // Documents: Artifacts of Modern Knowledge / Ed. by A. Riles. In press.

Miyazaki H., Riles A. Failure as an Endpoint // Global Assemblages:

Technology, Politics and Ethics as Anthropological Problems / Ed.

by A. Ong, S. Collier Malden. MA, 2004. P. 320331.

Riles A. The Network Inside Out. Ann Arbor, 2000.

Riles A. Property as Legal Knowledge: Means and Ends // Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute. 2004. Vol. 10 [new series]. No. 4.

P. 775795.

Strathern M. (Ed.). Audit Cultures: Anthropological Studies in Accountability, Ethics and the Academy. L., 2000.

2 Turner T. Representation, Politics, and Cultural Imagination in Indigenous Video: General Points and Kayaro Examples // Media Worlds:

Anthropology on the New Terrain / Ed. by F.D. Ginsburg, L. Abu Lughod and B. Larkin. Berkeley, 2002. P. 7589.

Verdery K. Faith, Hope, and Caritas in the Land of the Pyramids: Romania, 1990 to 1994 // Comparative Studies in Society and History. 1995.

Vol. 37. No. 4. P. 625669.

Wagner R. The Invention of Culture. Chicago, [1975] 1981.

Zournazi M. Hope: New Philosophies for Change. N.Y., 2002.

...

1 (, ).,,,, .

, , ,, ,. , ?, ;

, (-,.),., , - ,.

71 , , ( ), ?,, ? :

?

,,,,.,, - -, ( );

:,.

,, ( ) ;

( ).,,,,., , . ?

,,...

, .

, ( 2 , ).,,,,,.,, -.

.,, (,,,..) ( );

,,,..,, (, ), .

,.

: ( ) ( ).

. -,. , ( ).

, ( ) ;

,,,.,, -.

,,. ,

73 ,, .

,, 2..,, 2 2 = 4 2 2 = 5 ( ).

(),,,.

, 3,,.

,,.,. ( ), , ,.

:,,

, .,. , .

,

4 : .,, ( ),,,.

, 2 ,,,..

/.

,, ,.

, ,.

, ., -,,.

,, 1,,,,..

., ;

,,, ( ).,. ( ),,,.

, ( ). , 75 , ,,.,,, ,., :

,,,, -,,,,, ( ),,., :

., ( ),, .

, .

, - :,, - ., :

,,,.,,.

,,,,,., 2 , (, ), ;

.,,, -,..,,, ( )., -,,.

,, 2,,,,.,,,,,,.,,,,.

, ( ).,, ( ),,,,.

, .. -,,, 77 ,, -,.

,,.,, -.

3, (. ).,,., (, ),,,..,,.

,.,.

,.

-, (, ),,,,...

,, ().

,,,, ( ),,, ,,,,,. ? , 2 ., !

.,,.,, ,, (, ), -., 2004..

,,..,,. ().,, : ,,,,.,,,, . ( ), (, ).,,.

4 -,., (, ), 79 ., .

, 1, :

,,.,,,,., ,,.

,. :

-, (,.: [Riccoeur 1973]),,,...

,.,,,.,,.,,,, , , . . () , 2 ,,. ,.

, 2,,.,,,,,,,.

-,, ,,,.. : ,, .

. [Van Maanen 1988].

: (, ), (,..) (, )., () ;

, (,..).,,.,

[White 1973], XIX () (), () (), (), () ().

81 .

,, [Said 1979].

,.,,, (, Local Knowledge [Geertz 1983]), ( ) (.. [Geertz 1971]).

, [Caton 1990],, [Messick 1993],, [Dresch 1989] [Dresch 2000]., ,,,.

, 3 [Hayano 1979].

,,,,,., ( ),.,,.,,,. [Said 1999],,,,,,. 2 - : ( ),.,.

, -.,,., :

,.,, -: , - [Kubica 2002: XIV].

1983.

4,, -,,,... 2003..,,,,.,,,.,,,,,,,.,,,., .,, 83 .

,,.

,,,.

,.,,, -:

,, [Clarke 1975].

,,,.,.,.

Caton S. Peaks of Yemen I Summon. Poetry as Cultural Practice in a North Yemeni Tribe. Berkeley;

Los Angeles;

Oxford, 1990.

Clarke M. Survival in the Field // Theory and Society. 1975. No. 2. P. 6394.

Dresch P. Tribes, Government, and History in Yemen. Oxford, 1989.

Dresch P. A History of Modern Yemen. Cambridge, 2000.

Geertz C. Islam Observed. Religious Development in Morocco and Indo nesia. Chicago;

London, 1971.

Geertz C. Local Knowledge. N.Y., 1983.

Hayano D.M. Auto-ethnography // Human Organization. 1979. No. 38.

P. 99104.

Kubica G. Praga Magica // Prague Studies in Sociocultural Anthropology.

No. 2. / Ed. by P. Skalnik. Prague, 2002. P. XIIXV.

Messick B. The Calligraphic State. Textual Domination and History in a Muslim Society. Berkeley;

Los Angeles;

London, 1993.

Riccoeur P. The Model of the Text // New Literary History. 1973. No. 5.

P. 91120.

Said E. Orientalism. N.Y., 1979.

Said E. Out of Place: A Memoir. N.Y., 1999.

Van Maanen J. Tales of the Field. On Writing Ethnography. Chicago, London, 1988.

White H. Metahistory. The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe. Baltimore;

L., 1973.

2 ( ),,,,,,

(wie es eigentlich gewesen ist).,, (badge of office), ,.

(, , ).,,, - ,, :,,,,.,, (,, ), (, (Mark Steinberg) , ),, , 85 (, ).

,,...

, ( ),. (, )..,,, ;

,,,,.

,,,.

,,.

,,,, (,,,, ). .

,, .

,,. (Proletarian Imagination: Self, Identity and the Sacred in Russia, 19101925. Ithaca, 2002),,,, :,, 2 , ,.,,,,, ,,,,,.,..,,,,.,,,,.,,,.,,,, ,,.

, :

-,,,,,,,.,,. ,, ,,,,

.

, 87 ( ).,,,, ,.,,.,, ( ),,,,,, (, ).,.,, ( ):, ( ), (,,, )., (,, ).,.

,,,,,,..

,,,,,.,,, , -. ?,,,.

,, 2 ..

...

,., 1.

,,,,,,,,.

?..., ?

, ,, 100 %.

2 :

( ). (,.. ..),,.,, - .. 89 .

. 3.,,,, ( 1990-.)., - ;

,,., ,, .,.,,., -,, -.

,,,, (, ),.

,, ( ), (, ). -,,., : . ,, (,,,, ).,,, 2 ., 4 ( ) - ().

,,,,. /,,., /, ( ).

1 /,,,, 2030. ,,. , [c., : Clifford, Marcus 1986;

Marcus, Fischer 1986].

,, ,, , 91 ,, , ( ),

( ). ,,..,.

,,,.,,,, o., ( ),.,,, ,.,,.,, ,. ,, .

,, .,, .,, [, 2000;

2001],,,

[c.,, 2 2004.].

2 ?.

,,,,,,.,

. ,,..,,,.

,, , ,,,.

, ( ),.,,, , ,,.

., 1970- , () [ 2002]. ,,,, (, ), (, ).

93 , /.,,..,,,, (,,,,..) [ c.: Kaufmann 2003].

?,,,, ( ),,.. [ 1966: 118],. ? ( ) ?

,,, ().

,,. :,, [ 2002: 286],, ( ). , .

, 2,..,, 2 ,,.,, .,,. ( ),,.., 1.,.. ,.

(),.,,,,,,,., ,, [., : 2003: 182].,, . ,.,, ,..,,,.,,, ., , , 35. URL: http://www.nz online.ru/index.phtml?cid=3. .

: [, 2002, 2003;

2003].

95 , ,,,, (motif), [Gombrich 1989: 73].

, ,,.,, .

., ,., /. (,, -, ), -,.

. ;

,.

/ -, /.

,,, 2 . [Rabinow 1977].

.

,,. ( ).,,,.,,,.

3,.,,

(native anthropology),,,, - 1.

,, - (history from below) [., : Krantz 1988],

(subaltern studies) [., : Guha, Spivak 1988;

Guha 1997, 2001] [Bhabha 1994;

Chakrabarty 2000].

,,, //, ( ) [Seremetakis 1991].

97 .

,,,.

, -, ,,,,,,,.,, (+ ), , [Brown 1997;

Scott 2000, 2002].

- ,,,,, /... :,,, [, 1996].

, 4...,,,.

,,.

, 2 (), -,,., ( ),., ,. / :

.

.,. :

//. 2002. 5.. 186210 (. 1), URL: http:/ /magazines.russ.ru/logos/2002/5/soc.html;

. 2003. 2.

. 5187 (. 2), URL: http://magazines.russ.ru/logos/2003/2/ bikbov.html. ? //.. 2. /...

, 2001.. 649670.

..,.. (.) : ( ).., 2000.

....: (N):.. /.

...:, 2002 //. 2003. 5.. 185.

.,. . : -.., 1996.

.. 5. (1957/ 1958) /...., 2002.

.. (.). 2., 2001.

. : XIX., 2002.

. :.., 1966.

. 1.

.. //.

2003.. 3. 3.. 8389, URL: www.sociologica.ru/s9/ 09sta2.pdf Bhabha H. The Location of Culture. N.Y., 1994.

99 Brown W. The Impossibility of Women's Studies // Differences. 1997.

Vol. 9. No. 3. P. 79101.

Chakrabarty D. Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference. Princeton, N.J., 2000.

Clifford J., Marcus G. (Eds.). Writing Culture. The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography. Berkeley, 1986.

Gombrich E.H. Art and Illusion: A Study in the Psychology of Pictorial Representation. The A.W. Mellon Lectures in the Fine Arts, 1956.

Princeton, 1989.

Guha R. (Ed.). A Subaltern Studies Reader 19861995. Minneapolis, 1997.

Guha R., Spivak G.C. (Eds.). Selected Subaltern Studies. N.Y., 1988.

Kaufmann R. What is Construction, Whats the Aesthetic, What was Adorno Doing? // Aesthetic Subjects. / Ed. by P. Matthews, D. McWhirter. Minneapolis, 2003. P. 366396.

Krantz F. (Ed.). History from Below: Studies in Popular Protest and Popular Ideology. N.Y., 1988.

Marcus G., Fischer M. (Eds.). Anthropology as Cultural Critique. An Experimental Moment in the Human Sciences. Chicago, 1986.

Rabinow P. Reflections on Fieldwork in Morocco. Berkeley, 1977.

Scott J. Feminist Reverberations // Differences. 2002. Vol. 13 (3). P. 123.

Scott J. Fictitious Unities: 'Gender', 'East', and 'West'. Paper presented at the Fourth European feminist research conference. Bologna, Italy, Sept. 29, 2000. URL: http://orlando.women.it/cyberarchive/files/ scott.htm Seremetakis.N. The Last Word: Women, Death, and Divination in Inner Mani. Chicago, 1991.

1 (Geisteswissenschaften, Kulturwissens chaften),., / / ( ),.,, ;

(Michael Fischer) , 2 ,.,,.

,,,,.,

(), -,,,,,..,,,,,,,

,., ;

,,,,,,., ( ) ( ),, (,,, ). Verstehende Soziologie (,, ),,,,,,.

101 , Verstehende Soziologie,, :

,,.,, ( ), ( ), (,, ).

.

,, (..

),,,,, ( ,,,,,,, ).

.,, (,,, ),.,,,. 2 ,,, ;

,.

,,,, -., -,,,,, ,.,, ( ) ( ),,. XX.,,,,, / ( ),, XIXXX.,.

1980, ( ).,, ,,,, , . , ( / . .

.. . ., 1983. . 371;

: / . . . . ., 1999. . 541542). . .

103 , ,, .,,,,,,.,,, (..,, ),,,,,,,.

, (..,,, ), ( ),, ( ),, . (, ),.

2,,,,,. (,, ),,. 2 ,,,.,. 1.,,,.

,,,.

(,,,,,, .),,,, (,,, ).,.

, - un entretien (, ), ,,,,,,,.,,,,,.

, , , , .

105 . 3.

,, ( ) (,, -,,, ). ;

.

, ,,,,.,,,.,,,,,.

,,, [Tedlock 2004].

,,,,, : -, ,,, 1930-.,, -,,,,,,,,, [Radcliffe-Brown 1922, 1940].

,,,,,,,,.

2 (,,,,,,,,,,, )1.

,,,,,, XXI., (,..).

,,,,,,,, (direct-to consumer marketing),, (informercials),, (exploitative popular culture)2.

,.

, 4,.,, . (.).

Direct to consumer marketing , , , . , , , . Informercial , information

() commercial ( ) , , ( ). Exploitative popular culture , , , (MTV ).

107 ., ,,.,.,.

, :

Fischer M.M.J., Marcus G. Introduction to the Second Edition // Anthropology as Cultural Critique: An Experimental Moment in the Human Science. Chicago, 1999. P. XVXXXV.

Fischer M.M.J. Emergent Forms of Life and the Anthropological Voice.

Durham, NC, 2003.

Fischer M.M.J. Mute Dreams, Blind Owls, and Dispersed Knowledges:

Persian Poesis in the Transnational Circuitry. Durham, NC, 2004.

Radcliffe-Brown A. The Andaman Islanders: a Study in Social Anthropology.

Cambridge, 1922.

Radcliffe-Brown A. On joking relationship // Africa. 1940. Vol. 19. P. 140.

Tedlock B. The Observation of Participation and the Emergence of Public Ethnography. Handbook of Qualitative Research. 3rd ed. / Ed. by N.K. Denzin, Y.S. Lincoln. Thousand Oaks, CA, 2004 (in press).

...

, ,, -, , (Nancy Scheper Hughes) ,. 2 , .,,,. ( ), ---,.

,, ,.,, ,,, ,, ,.

, , -,, 1.

( ),,.,.

-,., [James 1973],,,,,,., -, : [Mohanty 1998;

Rationality and Relativism 1982;

Rationality 1985;

Tambiah 1990].

109 ,,,,,., ,,,,.,, ( ) ;

,,,,,.

XXI. ,,.

.,,,. : ( la -1) ;

2 [Scheper-Hughes 1995: 143164].


,, -,,,,,, :

, , , . [Evans Pritchard 1976].

, .

2 , [Buber 1952: 147156] ,, ?

- ( 1984),,,, ,, , ,. , menos um, [] angu [ ],,. 19931994.,, ,,,., (),,,,,, , [Scheper-Hughes 2002a: 197226;

Scheper Hughes 2002b: 6180;

Scheper-Hughes 2003: 16451648].

,,.,,,, ( )., -, .,, ( ) 111 ,,, ,,.,, : ,,,,, [Geertz 1988] .

:

, [c. Gilligan 1982;

Ruddick 1989]. ,,,,.

,.

, ;

,,, : ,, : [] [Levinas 1998: 100].

,,,

,. -,,,.

, - , : ,,,, [Sartre 1956].

,,,,,,, ( ),, 2 , .

-

[Abu-Lughod 1991: 13762], :,.

,,,,.,., 19931994.: ,,,, ?.,, ;

, , [ ]

[Farmer 2003: 24]. ,,,,,,.,,,.

,,,,,,, :

,.

113 , , [Piers 1978], (othering),,,.

,,,,,,,,,,,,,, -,,,,,,,, ( ).

. -

- .

,,,., .,, :

, ;

, ;

;

,,,,,. 2 .

?

,,,,.

,,,.

?

?,, ,,, , ,,,., nervoso infantil.

:, ;

,,, ;

,,,, - ;

,,,,,.

: ,,, -,,,,, 115 , ,.,,,.,,.

,,,. [ ] .

,, luta,,, ? (,,, ) ?

Tristes Antropologiques After the Fact [Geertz 1995],,,,.,,,,, [Starn 1992].

,,, 1965.,, (, ).,, ( ),,.

After the Fact 2 , ,, ,.,,,,, /.,,,,,,,,,..

-,, - [Lvi Strauss 1995]., , 19351939..,.,,.,,,,,,,,.,,, :,,,.

-,, , : ,,.,,,, 117 , ,,,.... [Lvi-Strauss 1961: 126].

-, : ,..., ;

, ;

[Malinowski 1945: 3].,. -.

Anthropology of Reason,. ( ) illusio,,,,,. /,.., ,.

, ( 2001.) [Bourdieu 2002].

( ),,, 2 ,,,,. ,, 2000.

[Bourdieu 2000],

,,, (,, )., , ,.

, Waiting: The Whites of South Africa (1985) ,,. ,....

( )...

..

,,.,,... [] [,, ], [ ] [Crapanzano 1985: 44].

,. ;

,,,.

,, .

,, 119 , , 1930-.,,,

[Powdermaker 1968].,,,,,,.

,., ,,, , ., companheira1, ;

,.

,.,,.

,, : (),.,, [Basaglia 1987] .,,,,,,,,,, :

,,.

[Scheper-Hughes 1993;

1995], antropologia-pe-no-chao, - Companheira (. . companheiras) ., , , . (. p. . . companheiro), , , , . . .

2 ,,, .,,,,,,. , companheiras (, ),, ( )., The Practice of Everyday Life [de Certeau 1984],, c, c. companheiras.

Abu-Lughod L. Writing Against Culture // Recapturing Anthropology. / Ed. by R. Fox. Santa Fe, 1991. P. 137162.

Basaglia F. Psychiatry Inside Out. N.Y., 1987.

Bourdieu P. Unite and Rule. Public lecture given in Tokyo. October, 2000.

Bourdieu P. Pour un savoir engag: Un texte indit de Pierre Bourdieu // Le monde diplomatique. 2002. Fvrier. P. 3.

Buber M. On the Suspension of the Ethical // The Eclipse of God: Studies in the Relation Between Religion and Philosophy. N.Y., 1952.

P. 147156.

Certeau M. de. The Practice of Everyday Life. Berkeley;

Los Angeles, 1984.

Crapanzano V. Waiting: The Whites of South Africa. N.Y., 1985.

Evans-Pritchard E.E. Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic Among the Azande.

Oxford, 1976 [1937].

Farmer P. Pathologies of Power: Health, Human Rights, and the New War on the Poor. Berkeley, 2003.

Geertz C. Works and Lives: The Anthropologist as Author. Stanford, California, 1988.

Geertz C. After the Fact: Two Countries, Four Decades, One Anthropologist.

Cambridge, 1995.

Gilligan C. In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Womens Development. Cambridge, Mass., 1982.

James W. The Anthropologist as Reluctant Imperialist // Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter / Ed. by Talal Asad. N.Y., 1973. P. 69.

Levinas I. Useless Suffering // Entre Nous: Thinking-of-the Other, translated by M.B. Smith and B. Harshaw. N.Y., 1998. P. 91103.

121 Lvi-Strauss C. A World on the Wane [= Tristes Tropiques]. N.Y., 1961.

Lvi-Strauss C. Saudades de Brasil. Seattle, 1995.

Malinowski B. The Dynamics of Culture Change. New Haven, 1945.

Mohanty S.P. Us and Them: on the Philosophical Bases of Political Criticism // Yale Journal of Criticism. 1998. No. 2 (2). P. 131.

Piers M. Infanticide. N.Y., 1978.

Powdermaker H. After Freedom. N.Y., 1968 [1939].

Rationality / Ed. by Bryan Wilson. Oxford, 1985.

Rationality and Relativism / Ed. by M. Hollis, S. Lukes. Cambridge, Mass., 1982.

Ruddick S. Maternal Thinking: Towards a Politics of Peace. London, 1989.

Sartre J.-P. Being and Nothingness: A Phenomenological Essay on Ontology. London, 1956.

Scheper-Hughes N. Death without Weeping: the Violence of Everyday Life in Brazil. Berkeley, 1993.

Scheper-Hughes N. Whos the Killer? Popular Justice and Human Rights in a South African Squatter Camp // Social Justice. 1995. No. (3). P. 143164.

Scheper-Hughes N. Rotten Trade: Millenial Capitalism, Human Values, and Global Justice in Organ Trafficking // Journal of Human Rights. 2002a. No. 2 (2). P. 197226.

Scheper-Hughes N. The Ends of the Body: Commodity Fetishism and the Traffic in Human Organs // School of Advanced International Studies Review: A Journal of International Affairs. 2002b. No. (1). P. 6180.

Scheper-Hughes N. Keeping an Eye on the Global Traffic in Human Organs // Lancet. 2003. No. 361. P. 16451648.

Starn O. Missing the Revolution: Anthropologists and the War in Peru // Rereading Cultural Anthropology / Ed. by G. Marcus. Durham, North Carolina, 1992. P. 152179.

Tambiah S. Magic, Science, Religion and the Scope of Rationality.

Cambridge, 1990.

...

. . () , 2 ( confessional [Jenkins 1993: 442], ( ) (anthropology at home).

,.

/,. :

,,,,.. .,.. - :,,..,., ;

,,,,, -

[Harvey 1996: 13].. [Harbsmeier 1995: 21, 32].,,.,.

1.

( ,, ),,..,.

-, ( ) (,,, ).

1970- 123 ,, ,.... ( ), (The Anthropology of Anthropology: The Brazilian Case, 1981), 19601970-., [Hallowell 1974],, -,, . 1980-. ( 1980-,, [Strathern 1985]),. ,

,, .

., [Peirano 1998: 110;

Stocking 1982].

1990-..,, 1980-,,.

. : ? :

,, [Aunger 1995: 97].,, :

, ( 2 . ),, (

indigenous). (non-native).

,, 1980-,,.,, -,,,. 1960 1970-.,... ( ) ,,, ( ).

(, ).

.

,..,, [ 1995: 52],, /,, ( 1920- ), ( ). .

,,,., ( ), 125 , .. - .,,,,,.,,,,.,,,,.,,,, /,.

( ),,.

, , ,, :., :

, ( ),.,,,.,. - ,.,., 2 ,.. (-) :,, , , ?,,, [Shokeid 1997: 631]. -,,,.,,,,,,. ( ),,.,, (, )., -,,.

,,, .

, ,..

, (, )..,,

1.

[ 2003;

2003b].

127 ,,, ,.

,,,.,., ( ),, (,, ).,,,.

( ) , ( ).,,.,. , ,, ,, [c. : Peirano 1998: 113;

Clifford 1997: 90].

2 2.

,, .. , , [Strathern 1987]. , ()

() ;

() ( ). , , , ,...

,, 1960-.... [Peirano 1998: 108, 112], ,, - [Lvi Strauss 1961], [Goody 1966], [Stocking 1983].

,,.,,, (,, )., (,,

),, .

...,,,,, 129 . , , , (, ).,,.

- /.

.,,,... (standpoint),, (-- ).

.,., ,,,,,, [ 2002: 31],.... (male stream ): ,, , [Abbot, Wallace 1997: 4]., ,..

, -,,, (.

, ). 2 (,,, ), ( ).

(, muted).

,., (indigenous).,,.,, [Diamond 1980: 1112]. ,. ,, :,, [Peirano 1998: 109].

,,., ( ),, [Ardener 1985: 24].

., () - (non-native),.., ( ),,, (,,,, ),.

,. , 131 , .,,,,,.

.

, (

, ).,.,,,,,,, :.,,, ,,.,,,.

,. :,,..

;

,.,. ,,,,,,,. . ,,,, [Jenkins 1993: 443]., ( ), ,.

,,,.

,,, ( ) 2 ,. ,.

, , -...,,, :

[Ibid]..,, ,.,, ,,,,. (), .

,,,,,.., ,. . ( ) ,..,.,,,,.

,, (, ),,.

133 . //. 1995. 3.. 4554.

.. : // : /....., 2000.. 2963.

.. : //. 2003a.. VI. 2.. 165179.

.., // V., 912 2003.:..., 2003b.. 321.

Abbot P., Wallace C. An Introduction to Sociology. Feminist Perspectives.

L.;

N.Y., 1997.

Ardener Sh. The Social Anthropology of Women and Feminist Anthropo logy // Anthropology today. 1985. October. Vol. 1. No. 5. P. 2426.

Aunger R. On Ethnography. Storytelling or Science? // Current Anthropology. 1995. February. Vol. 36. No. 1. P. 97130.

Clifford J. Routes: Travel and Translation in the Late Twentieth Century.

Cambridge, 1997.

Diamond S. Anthropological Traditions: The Participants Observed // Diamond S. Anthropology: Ancestors and Heirs. Paris, 1980.

P. 1112.

Goody J.R. The Prospects for Social Anthropology // New Sociology. 1966.

Oct. 13. P. 574576.

Hallowell Al. The History of Anthropology as an Anthropological Problem // Readings in the History of Anthropology / Ed. by R. Darnell. N.Y., 1974. P. 304321.

Harbsmeier M. Towards a prehistory of ethnography: early modern German travel writing as traditions of knowledge // Fieldwork and Footnotes:

Studies in the History of European Anthropology / Ed. by F.V. Han, A.A. Roldan. London;

N.Y., 1995. P. 1939.

Harvey P. Hybrids of Modernity: Anthropology, the Nation State and the Universal Exhibition. London, 1996.

Jenkins T. Fieldwork and the Perception of Everyday Life // Man (N.S.), 29. 1993. P. 433455.

Lvi-Strauss C. La crise moderne de lantropologie // Le Courrier (UNESCO). 1961. No. 14 (11). P. 1217.

Peirano M.G.S. When Anthropology is at Home: The Different Contexts of a Single Discipline // Annual Review of Anthropology. 1998.

Vol. 27. P. 105128.

Shokeid M. Negotiating Multiple Viewpoints: The Cook, the Native, the Publisher, and the Ethnographic Text // Current Anthropology.

Vol. 38. No. 4. 1997. AugustOctober. P. 631645.

Stocking G.W. Afterword: a View from the Center // Ethnos. 1982. No. 47.

(12). P. 172186.

2 Stocking G.W. History of Anthropology: Whence/Whither // Observers Observed. Essays on Ethnographic Fieldwork. Ed. by G.W.Jr. Stoc king. Madison, 1983. P. 312.

Strathern M. Not a Field Diary Anthropology at Home with the Association of Social Anthropologists // Anthropology today. 1985.

June. Vol. 1. No. 3. P. 2526.

Strathern M. The Limits of Auto-anthropology // Anthropology at Home.

ASA Monographs, 25. Ed. by A. Jackson. N.Y., 1987. P. 1637.



 
 >>  ()





 
<<     |    
2013 www.libed.ru - -

, .
, , , , 1-2 .