, , ,

<<


 >>  ()

...

..,..

:

2013

330.34:338.2:504.03

20.1 + 65.05

50

: -

,..

[ ]: /

..,..// - -...

.. [ ]..:, 2013. URL:

http://www.ipu.ru/sites/default/files/page_file/GreenTech.pdf. 1.. (CD-R). .

.. (3,2 ).. : IBM PC, Internet Explorer, Acrobat reader 3.0....

0321301152. ISBN 978-5-91450-132-4.. ,...

-., ,. ,.

.

,,,,,,,.

:

..,...,.,.....,...,.,....

, ISBN 978-5-91450-132-................................................................................................ 1. :

.......................................................................... 1.1. 1.1.1.

........................................................................................................... 1.1.2.

......................................................................... 1.2.

.................................................................................... 1.2.1.

................................................................. 1.2.2............... 1.2.3.

...................................................................... 1.2.4........................................... 1.2.5.

....................................................................................... 1.2.6................................................................. 1.2.7.

....................................................................................... 1...................................................................... 2.

.................... 2.1....................................................... 2.1.1. -

........................................................................................................... 2.1.2.................... 2.2. ............... 2.2.1........................... 2.2.2......................................................................... 2.2.3........................................................................................ 2.2.4.

..................................................................................... 2.3.

.................................. 2.3.1.

........... 2.3.2. :

?................................................................................. 2.3.3. ............................................................................. 2.................................................................... 3.

...................................................................................... 3.1.,......................................................... 3.1.1. .............................................. 3.1.2.

.................. 3.1.3. ............. 3.1.4. .............................. 3.2.

............................................. 3.2.1.

: ................................................... 3.2.2.,......................................................................................................... 3.3.

................................ 3.3.1.

........................................................... 3.3.2.

................................................................................. 3.3.3.

.......................... 3.3.4.

......... 3.................................................................... 4.

.............................................................. 4.1.

... 4.1.1.

. 4.1.2.

............................................................... 4.1.3.

............... 4.2.

......... 4.2. ................................................................... 4.2.2.

............................................ 4.2.3.

....................................... 4.3.

... 4................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................,,,,.

, .

,.,,,.

,..,.

, :., ,..,.

..

,,. [124].

,, ,, [78].

,,.

,,, ,.

,..

,....,.

, - .

, -.

,. ?

(, )

-.

.

,.,,, ,..,,,.,,,, . [29],,..

-,.

, ..,, -,,.

: , ,..

. , .

,,,.

,.,,,.

[61],,,,.

, ( ), R. Hueting [107]. More welfare through less produc tion,.. . [115],.

, .

,,,..

,,,.,

., [69], ( ),.,,,.

,,,,, .

, : ?, -,., , - ?

.., , [72]., ,,.

: ,..,. , ,, (, ),,, ( ),.,,

.

, ,,...,..

[54],,,..

, ,.

(.,, [35]),,..

,.

[61, 83].

.,,, ,., [69, 70].,,,.

,

,,,. .

,,,.,.

(,.. ),,,,.

,.

, ,,,.

,,,

. .

, , (,, ).

:

?

,..?

, ?

,, ?

?

...

.

,, ?

(, ) , -.

, (, ), -. ( ), (, ),, .

.

1. : 1.1.

,,., ,,.

.

.

.

,..

, , :

;

,.,,, [78].,, ;

, (,, ;

,,,,..).

. 1.1 ,.

1.1.

, -, - -,, -..

,,,,,.,,..

,.,,, CO22.

. 3.3.1.

, CO2 ..

,, ,,,,, ,,,.,,,.

1.1.1.,.,, [88].

, 1998-2000., 51237-98, ,,.

( ), :

( );

,. [98, 102].. 2.2.

( 1, 100 1, 5 99, 5 );

(, ),.

,,,.

.

: ( ), ( ) ( ).

.

( ), ( ) ( ).

. - ( ),,,,.

6, 126, - 200, - 120.

,,,, Global Wind Energy Council.

...

, 30.,.

, ( 51594-2000).,.

( ),. ( ),.

. ,.,.,,,, :,..

,.

,.

,.

.,.,,.,

.

, CSG- (Crystalline Silicon on Glass), CdTe ( - ) CIS-, -,,, ( CIGS).

18%.

( 51594-2000).

,.

.,,.

, -,,.

,.

.

-,. -,.

( ) ( ).

,,.

(, ),.

( ),.

-,, ( 4050 ), (,,,, ).

,..,, 10 ( 50 ).

( ) 10 000.

( ) 30 000.

100 ( 51238-98).

-.

,, 5 :

;

( );

( ;

, ( 2 );

,, 1300 .

,.

( 19%), (4% ) ( 1%).

., ,,.,,,,. ( ),,.

. ( ), 3-4, 5-.,,.

:,,.

, Empire State Building.

,.

,.,,.

:

,.

,,,,,,, ,..

(. [20]).

, :,,.. ($4050 ),.

,,

( grass gasoline ). ,, [129].

..

-,,,,.,,.

,,..,.

,,,.

[24]:, 625.

, 31....,

2011. 513...;

2012. ( ) 528...,.....

, (,, ) ,,,.

, 20...

.,,., , (,. [2]),...

,,.

( ) .. (. [20])., ,,,., ( ).

,,,.

,..

,,.,,,. [91].

,,..,...

( ),,...

. (, ) ( ).,....

(, ). :

(, ),,,,..

,,, (, ).

1.1.2.,. (..

),.,,.,,, 1% (, ),.. 99%, ?,, ( ),,.,, , (energy returned on energy invested, EROEI):

Energy Re turned EROEI =, EnergyExpanded Energy Re turned -, ;

EnergyExpanded -.

(NEG, net energy gain):

NetEnergy NEG =, EnergyExpanded NetEnergy = Energy Re turned EnergyExpanded ,..,, ( NEG ). :

EROEI = NEG + 1, ,.,, EROEI=5,. EROEI,,, ,. [109] EROIE (.. 1.2),.

1.2.

EROIE - EROIE EROIE Cleveland, C.J. 2005. Net en 1930 ergy from oil and gas extraction in theUnited States, 19541997.

Energy 30: 769782.

Yandle, B., M. Bhattarai & M.

1999 Vijayaraghavan. 2004.

( ) Environmental kuznets curves:

a review of findings, methods, and policy implica tions. PERC 2:138.

Hall, C.A.S. 2008. Reports pub 2005 ( - lished on The Oil Drum, ) http://www.theoildrum.com/ Cleveland, C.J. 2005. Net en 2000 ergy fromoil and gas extraction in theUnited States, 19541997.

Energy 30: 769782.

Lenzen, M. 2008. Life cycle en 5- ergy and greenhouse gas emissions of nuclear energy: a review. Energy Conversion Manage. 49: 21782199.

Hall, C.A.S. 2008. Reports pub lished on The Oil Drum.

http://www.theoildrum.com Kubiszewski, I.,C.J.Cleveland&P.K.Endres.

2010.Metaanalysis of net en ergy return for wind power sys tems.Renewable Energy 35:

218225.

Hall,C.A.S., C.J. Cleve 1, land&R.Kaufmann. 1986. En ergy and Resource Quality:

TheEcology of theE conomicProcess. Wiley. New York.

- Hall,C.A.S., C.J. Cleve 1, land&R.Kaufmann. 1986. En ergy and Resource Quality: The Ecology of the Economic Proc ess. Wiley. New York.

Battisti, R. & A. Corrado. 2005.

6, Evaluation of technical im ( - provements of photovoltaic sys ) tems through life cycle assess ment methodology. Energy 30:

952 Goldemberg, J. 2007. Ethanol (- 0,8- for a sustainable energy future.

) Science 315: 808810.

Farrell, A.E., R.J. Pelvin, B.T.

(- 0,8-1, Turner, et al. 2006. Ethanol can ) contribute to energy and envi ronmental goals. Science 311:

506508.

Hall, C.A.S. 2008. Reports pub 1, lished on The Oil Drum.

http://www.theoildrum.

,, EROEI -,.,, 1930. XX XXI. EROEI,,. EROEI,, .. :.

EROEI,,,

,..,,,., EROEI :,,,,,..?,,,, ?, EROEI?

(,. [35]).

,,.,. EROEI.

, EROEI,,,,.,, , EROEI,,.. Energy Re turned.

[18, 28], .,,,,.,,,,,,..

, (..),.

, .,,,,,.

., ,,,, -.

1.2.

1.2.1.. 2010, ,,.,,. ( ) .

( ) , CO2 2005. (.. BLUE).

(..1.3).

1. BLUE 2, - 2,,, 50% - 84%, 32%, 7% 64% 57%, 4%, - 20% ;

;

- 36%;

12%;

138%, 85% 40% - 2 76%,, - - 67 / / 2/3 48%, -, - 23%, 22%, ( ) -17% - 9,4, (55%), (21%) BLUE:

2007 2050. [58].

(24%).

2 (, 2/ ), 80% - 80%,, -,, - ;

90% - 50% 2 -,,, 270 316..( 17%.., ), -,, 90%,, - 30% 2007, - 2, 70-80% 2007.

1.2.2.

2010-2015,, 2 (, ),.., 1,2..

,,,,.

,..

Pew Charitable Trusts, 2010 30% $243.

2004 630%.

$54,5, $ (. 1.1).

, $41,2.,,,.

$34, (43%), 25%, 17%.

.1.1 2010 (.., PEW Charitable Trusts),,,.

.

.

,,.,, ( ).,.

1.2.3..

2009 42.1%.

, 159213, 38312 ( 24%) 2009.

(WWEA) 1900000 2020.

2009. 50, - (47.9% )(. 1.2).

.1.2. ,, .,, 2011. (. 1.3).

. 1.3 ( ). 18 000 MB, 6,.,, C. 2010, 25% ( ), 42% 2009, 43% 2008, 34% 2007, 18% 2006,12% 4% 2000 2004.

2010, (680 ), 2292 2009 2671 2008.

. 3000 (. 1.4).

. 1.4 ( ),., ( 95%),.

. 1.5.

,,.

., 2011 -1,. 7.. EnBW.

21 SWT-2,3-93 Siemens 2,3, 160, 93.

60,. 48,3, 185 /. 50.

-2.

80 3, SWT-3,6- -2 Siemens.

2013.

. 1.5 ( ),,,,,,,. 20,.

, (,, ).

7 ( / ), 4150,. 25% 30, 15% 30 60 60%,, 60.

,,.

,,., -,,,,.,,,, -,.

,.

,, -,,.,,, -,,.,,,,.

1.2.4.

(EPIA) 2011. 28.

67,4 (. 1.6),.

. 1. 200-2011.

. 2011 (9,3 7,5 ).

60% 2011 (. 1.7).

. 1.7,, (.1.4) 1., - / 2011., 2011., 9 284 12754 212, 7485 24678 302, 1671 2659 40, 974 2018 183, 784 875 13, 426 631 58, 372 4400 93, 321 468 85, 6 1959 185,,,..

,,,, (.1.5)..

1., / 2011, 2200 3093 2, 1296 4914 774 1298 56, 300 461 0, 92 754 15, 70 102 4, / 11 0, (. 1.6).

, 2,4., 967. - (263 ), ( ), - (139 ) (118 ).

1., / 2011, 1855 4383 13, 364 563 16, 10 40 0, 5 32 0, ( ).

10., 1,5.. 80%. 150.

.,.. 10%.

( ). 40% /,,. 2008 1,4.. 2,2.

15%. / 18 000 -25.. 2008 210 000, 2007 60%. 40% [116].

1,2. 11,3...,,,.,,.

, 2008,, 2005. 3,8%,,., /....,. 66% 33%. - ( ),,,.

1.2.5.

,,. 1861 1600.

1946 1952, 4.

7000.

. 90% 2008.

. 75 [130].

(. 1.8),,.,. 30% [125]. 51.

. 1. 2011.

.,,,. (21%), (17,5%), (15,5%), (9,6%) (9,4%) (.

1.9,. [130]).

. 1. ,, ).

,,.,,. 1.7.

1., 1990 1995 2000 2005 0 0,2 0,2 0,2 1. 0 0 0 1 1, 0 33,4 33,4 33 0 0 0 0,2 6, 144,8 309,8 589,5 797 44,6 50 170 322 545 631,7 785 790 45 45 45 127 19,2 28,8 29,2 28 - 0 55 142,5 163 700 753 755 953 35 70 70 77 283,2 286 437 435 0 0 0 39 3 5 16 16 11 11 23 79 95 105 161 151 2774,6 2816,7 2228 2544 0,3 0,3 0,3 0,3 0, 20,6 20,4 20,4 20,4 ( - 4,2 4,2 4,2 15 ) 891 1227 1909 1931 0 0 8,5 7 7, 214,6 413,7 546,9 535 5831,7 6866,8 7974,1 9064,1 10716, (. 1.10).

. 1. ( ) 1995-. 1.11, - 2010.

.1. 2000-2010.

., ( ),,.

,,.,, 2-2,5 ( ).

, 80%.,,.

.

.

15, 2010 100 120000,,,. 2-3.. 50% 10 (,,,,,,, -, ) (EIA, 2008). 70%, 30%. 90%, ( - ).

Ball State, University, 40 [131].

. 2010 58%, 13% 2.. 80 000 [116].

2008 62 000, 2008 350 000. (. 1.12).

121 300, 1,.., 12.2% [116].

. 1.12 2003 2008.

, 2008 580 489. 50% 2007, 4,35.. (. 1.13).

. 1.,,,.

, 2009-2012,,,,,..,.

,.

,, ( )., 4500 / 4.5. 4.7 [116].

1.2.6.

( ) (. 1.14).

. 1.14 2009 (.

), (.. 1.1).

, (. 1.15).

2007, (Energy Independence and Security Act) 36. 2022,,, 21.,..,.

. 1. (. 1.16).

,,,.,,.

. 1. (. ) 5-10,,,,,.

, 2009. 10,2. 16,6% 2008.

35% 2008 (54% 65% 2005 ),,.,,,.

-,,,,,,,,,,.

., ( 99),.

. B,,.

2009.,,,,. 2010,.

1.2.7.

-,, ,..,.

,,..,,.,, [35].

,,.

.. S-,.. 1.17.

, (i-1)- i- (i+1). 1.17.

(,..,. 1.17),.

,,, S.

,.

,.,,,.

., S-,,,.

,.. ( ) .

.. ,, ,., ( S ),,,

,.

,,,,, -..,,,.

,,, ,.

,..

.,... .

,, .

, , .

.

( 1%) : 2011, 100237.

6735 2010 2011, 6,8%. :

12- 0,7%, 2%.

(..1.8).

.

,,.

,,, ,, 50%,.

,.

..,,.., . ,,,.

, .

1. 2010 2011-2012 2011- 43934 52503 65 571 13 068 22% 24916 24064 27537 3 473 14% 11744 17722 23 910 6 188 35% 12908 5 948 6 933 985 17% 92502 100237 123 951 23 714 24% -,, ( ). -,, [55], ( ),.,,, .

-, -

. The Solar Foundation, [133].

,,,.

,, [78].

,,, .

,,,. .

, . .

,, ,,,, .,,,,,, 2020. 1,2% 3,9%, 1995-2009., 2020-2030. 0,9% [59].

,,.,

,, ,.,,. :,,

,,,,.

1.,

,..

,.., -,...

2.

, ( 10-20 ).

, ( ).

3.

, (..

).,,.

2.

2.1. 2.1.1. -

: ?

?

,.

.,, ( )..,,,,.,, ,.

,,. 5, ( ) 15-20,, 50-60, (,..).

500-600...

,, 10.;

1.;

. 20-25 -,. [33]..

.

( ) ( ) 40-44 /,.. - 1.

,, ,,,,,..

.

, (, ), 10 25 /,. [62].

1 5-6 / 10-12, 100-300 /, 3-10,.,,,,, 800-900 /,,..

,,..,,,,.

,,,,,, (,, ).

. : 1-,,,.

, 24.

,, (, ),.

.

T, l, (..

) g. 0

,. N., :

T D0 = N g 0.

l, D0 S.

S.,,,,. [48] (,.. ;

) 1.

,,,,,,, :

l1 l0, 1.,, ( g1 g 0 ),,, g g : 1 0., l1 l .

,, ,.

T : N g1 S.

l ?

,.,, .,,,.,,, N1 ), (,,,..

T T + ( N N1 ) g 0 S.

D1 = N1 g l1 l, :

g S N T l N1 N1max =.

g1 g T l1 l, (.. ) ,., .

,,., , ( ).

g g 2): 2 1 2, ( l2 l, .. ,, [82].

,,,, -,.

: N 2 N1max, max...

, (,,, ),,,,., ( ) ,,, ,, , (. [48]),..

[49].

C,,.

, (,..,...

,,.,.,, [29, 127]),,,,,,.,,.,

,. [124]., ,,, , -.,,, -.

2.1.2.

,,,.

.,, ,,..

,,,., (.. ).

(.,, [25, 35]).

:.. [37].

,.,,, (,,,, ),,,,, (, ), ..

,, (,,..),.. 2.1.

. 2.1.

( ):

1), ( );

2), ;

3) -,.

, :

I.,, /.

II., /.

III. ( ),,.

., - ,..,, 2000-. - ,,, 40-50%.

.,.

,,,,...,,,. ( ), ( ),,.

IV., ( I II, ).,,,,.

,,,..,, ( II).

,, - luxury goods, ( III).,,,,,.

,, ( I).,,,.

,,,, (. [48]) ,,. , (, , ).

IV (,,, ),,,., , -,,,.,,., ,.

( ).,,,.

,-,,, -, ( ).. :

1), ;

2),,, :

2.1) ;

2.2) ;

2.3),.

. 2.2.,,, ( ),,,.

,, (.. ).

( ( ) ) ( ( I) I, II, III). 2.2.

I.

,,,....

II III.,., II III.

I, II III, IV .,,.

?

III,,,.,,.

.

. ,,.

,,,.

,., (..

),.

I II,,,, (,,..).

. -,.

2.2.

,,,.,,, ,,,., ,, /.

- ,... -.

..

(, ).

,,, .., .

,,, . :

,,..

[11].

, ,..

, ., .

(..

,.

2.1.1)... ....,,,, ,...,,. , ,,

( !)

.,. 2.1.1,, ( )., ( ),, -.

(,. [8].

,,...

, [98, 102]).

, ,, (..,,. 1.1.2, EROEI ).,,, (.,, [18]).

, 15, -225 250 [50], ( ).,,. ( ),. [96],..

,..,,.,,,,,. [27]., (,, ),.

,,.

,.,,,,.

2.2.1.

,.., :

,,,,,.,,.,. [35]. The 1865.,, Coal Question, XIX,,,,..

, ,.

-,. [6]. ( !) .

..,.,,,, ( ), 2, (..),,, (,, ).

,,,,,.,,.,,, (.,, [105])., (. [105, 119]),, ,.

[106, 114].,, -, .

..,. [10].

-,..,,.

, .,,,, :

,.,,, ,.

.

g., ( ), q :

G = g q.

G (q),. :

p,..

: q = q ( p) ;

:

p = p( g).

:

G ( g ) = g q p ( g ).

, G 0 ( :, g g ).

, :

g q G q ( ) { } g q p ( g ) = q + g = q 1 + = q 1 + q 0, = g g g g q g q g q = - g g q.

,, :

q = q g.

p g p , . ( p = p( g) ) -.,,, (..,.. ),..

,,,. ( a ) (, ).

, p :

p(g ) = a + p g.

a0,, 1,..

1%, 1%:

p g p g g = p = 1.

g p a + p g, p g 1, .,,, (. [122]).,,,. M,, :

M q=.

p,, (.., ), ,,. [25, 35]., -1, 1., . p = p( g) q = q ( p) :

M g M G ( g ) = g q p ( g ) = g =.

p(g) a + p g, :

1),,, :

a g. a g,.,,,., (.,, [114]).

[106] ( ).,.

2), (, ).

.

3),. ., (..

),.

,.

,.,.,.. I II,,, (, I..) qmin.

,., :

( ) M min = qmin p I = qmin a I + p I I gI.

:

I M q I = min I ;

qmin.

I a + p g M min. :

( ).

M qmin a I + p g I I II q = max 0;

a II + p g II,.

gI g I. ?

.

a) ( ) ), I I I (.. M a +p g qmin, g I qmin.

g I qmin I I,,,,, ?., ) ( g I g I qmin.

I ) ( g I g I qmin I II g II a +p. :

).

( g I M qmin a I + p I I I II G = g qmin +g II II a +p g ( ).

M qmin a I + p I gI I I II G=g qmin +g II II a +p g :

) ( g I g I qmin I ) ( I I I II G G = g g qmin g = a II + p g II g II ) ( I I I 1 II 0, = g g qmin II a + p g..

.

b), (..

) ( g I ), M qmin a I + p I. I g M G=, a + p gI I I g M G =.,, g I I a +p G G.

c),.. :

( ) M qmin a I + p I gI ) ( g I I I M qmin a + p gI M G=, aI + p g I ), ( g I M qmin a I + p I I I II G = g qmin +g II II a +p g,.

G :

G ) ( M qmin a I + p g I I gI M I I II G G = g qmin g = aI + p g I a II + p g II aI + p g I I gI g II M g I g II II qmin = = I II a + p g I a + p g II a + p g II g I gI g II g II M I = I II II a + p gI a + p g II a + p g I a + p g II gI g II g I = I ) ( M qmin a I + p I II a + p g qI aI + p ) ( I a + p g II g I min g I g II ) ) ( ( qmin a I + p g I = X qmin a I + p g I.

I I II I a + p g II I a + p g ) ( g I 0, qmin a I + p I,, X...

M 1, ) ( g I I I a +p qmin g I gI g II g II = X I II II a + p g I a + p g II a I + p g I a + p g II g I gI = 0, aI + p g I aI + p g I, G G 0, G G,...

,,.

.

,.

II II,, g g.,.

, .

(, ).

,,,..

,,,.

,.,,., x,,,,.

,, :

M = p+, p x -.

M..

.

(,. [60]): , M,,.., , II,, III: x III x II.

: g III g II., III II a.

:a,, ., ( ).

,,.. (,, ).

,, :

M M M p III + = a III + p g III + a II + p g II +.

x III x III x II,, :

( ).

a III a II + p g III g II M M* = (2.1) 1 II III x x, III, II...,,, ,.,.,,,. g III.

g III, (1), :

,,.

)M, ( g III g II a III a II + p M * = * 1 II III x x,,.

,,,, .

,,.. M M *,,.,,..

: M M*,,,,,.

,,.

, . : M * M M *.

( ), M qmin a I + p I gI I I II G=g qmin +g (2.2) II II a +p g ( ).

M qmin a I + p I gI III I I G = g qmin +g (2.3) III III +p g a :

g III g II ( ) G G = M qmin a I + p g I II (2.4) I a + p g II a III + p g III, g III g II 0, a II + p g II a III + p g III g III g II.

a II + p g II a III + p g III, :

g III g II p p.

a II + p g II g III a II + p p II p III,,..,,.,,,,.,,,.

, III,,.,..

,, II.

III a III g II,.. g II a ( ),, (2.4),...

,,,, ....

,,.,,., (, ).

., ,,,,.

2.2.2.,...

, , (, ),,.

, ,.,,..

(. [105]).

backfire effect,,.

,. n n = .

, n = 100 10%, ( 1%).

i = 1,..n, i , Mi.

. I 2007. ( [87]).

N, n N., 2007.

143.. [132], 14,..

2.,./.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10,, :

Nn Gi ( M i ), G = (2.5) n i = Gi ( M i ) - i,, Mi., :

Nn G = Gi ( M i ) G, (2.6) n i = ( ).

, {G } {Gi }, i,,.

.

.

I g = 0,01, a I = 0,5. I qmin = 2000.

, a II = 0,5 ) II g = 0,01 (, III III = 0,05 ;

a = 1,0.

:g, II III, x = 50 = 500. x = 0,005.. 2.1. , 1%,.,. 2.1,.

. 2.3.

70.

60.*./ 50.

, 40 30 20 10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90. 2.3 ( ). 2.4 (2.2, 2.3, 2.5, 2.6), 0,1 0,02.

25, 50 100../..

.

./.

, 20 0 0,02 0,04 0,06 0,08 0,1 0, III. 2.4. ( ),.,. :

n ) = N G ( ( ), G i n i = n ) = N G ( ( ), G i n i = {G ( )}, {G ( )}, i = 1,...n - i i i-, (2.2, 2.3).

,. * * G., ( ).

I) ( * ), (,.. ( ), G = G = * * * * )..

II), ( ) ( G = G, * *,.. ).

() = G1 G, * * -1

.

. (I) (.. ), (II) ,..,.

, 0,1, * * = 17.. /. = 48,1../.

G ( ). 0,05.. 2.4,,..., II), 17.. /.

, = G1 (17. ) = 55, *../.,.. 15,8%. 2.2, (2.2, 2.3, 2.5, 2.6),.

2. ( ) - I II III II III III 0,1 48,1 279,7 1285,7 13,4 0,05 55,7 278,7 812,5 121,518. 15,8% - - 810% -28,1% 0,4% 36,8%,, (,.

100-, 93- ),.

,, (, ),.. 2. 85- 95-, (25 50../. ).,,,, 18860 37170./.. 2. 0,1 0,05 (.. ).

,,.,,. 2.5 2.6.

(2.2, 2.3),,.

,,,,

.

.

./.

, 0 0,02 0,04 0,06 0,08 0,1 0, III 85- ;

25 85- ;

50 95- ;

25 95- ;

. 2. 85 95- ( )./.

, 0 200 400 600 800,../.

85- ;

0,1 85- ;

0,05 95- ;

0,1 95- ;

0,. 2.6 85- 95- ( ), .,.,,. 2.5,....

., ( ),..., -, . , -,,.

2.2.3. -, -, .,, ( ).,, .,,,,,.

.

.

) ( ), I I I,..M a +p g qmin,. M qI =, a + p gI I :

M g I p aI + p gI q I p I q = I= = p ( ) p M q aI + p g I gI p =.

aI + p gI,.

) (..

:

( ) ), I I I M a +p g qmin ) ( ( M qmin a I + p g I ), I aI + p g I qI M = (..

) ( qI a I + p g I qmin a + p g I I I ( ) M qmin a I + p I g I ),, ) I I qI a + p g =.

qI aI + p g I,,,., ( ), ).

) ), ( ) :

gI p I q.

p aI + p gI,,,,., 49%, 52,7%., (15,8%),,.

. 2.7 20.

, 4 7- ( 1-3- )., ) 1-3- 7,2%, ( 49% 15,8% 7, 9% ). 4-7-,.

I 2.

2./ 2, 1 1 1 1 1 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18. 2.7. ( ) ), ), ( a + p g I I I M qmin. I, qmin.

, ,.,.

,, ( ).

,.,,,,,,, 100%, )., ( ) :

g II p II q.

p a II + p g II..

2.8., 100% 4-7-, ( 1-3 ), 93-99-,.

. 8-92-,, ), -, ,,, .

49%.,, 49% 15,8% 7, 9%., ( 7,71% 92-, 98,3% 8- ).

II 10% 0% -10% -20% -30% -40% -50% -60% -70% -80% -90% -100% -110% 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90. 2.8. ( ), ( ). .,,.

,,.

,,, ( ),.

2.2.4.

,. 2..,..

,,,,.,,.,,,, :

,, (,,,,. [3],.)...

., (. :, ). [33]:,,...

,.

,.

.,,..,.

,... ,,.

,.. ( ) -.,, ( ) -.

, -, ( ), ,.

,...

,.

,.,,.

,.

,,,,..

.

,.

,,, (.,, [105]).,,.,, (, ),.

,,.

,,...

, ( , ).,,, ?

.,.

2.2.3,,.

,.

,.,., , ( ).,. [33].,,, .., .

.

(, ). -.

,.,

,.

,,,...

.

.

-,,.,, (, ).

-,,,., ( ), :

g III g II p p, (2.7) a II + p g II g III t + a III + p t-,., III -,, II,..

2.2.1, III:

M M g III + t + a III + p a II + p g II + x III x II -, M*, III... M M a III + p g III + a II + p g II +, (2.8) x III x II :

1 a III + p g III a II + p g II + M II III x x III 1 g III a II + p t + a III + p g II + M II III, (2.9) x x,, :

1 a II + p g II + M II III x g III x II.

a II + p g II g (2.8), :

III g III g III a + p p III II =, g II g II p II a +p.. III.,....

, : III III III III III III g +p g a +p g, g a g III III g III a + p II, g II g II a +p :

g III g II p p, a II + p g II g III a III + p, III, , II ,. 2.2.2,.

(2.7, 2.8, 2.9), (.., ) III,,.,,.,.

,.

, , (, ).,,,.

- ,.

2.3.

2.3.1.,,..

,.. 2..,,,,,...

, ( ).,,.

,,.,.

III,..

.. 2.2.2, II,..

,,... .

III II I IV..

II I I I;

- I / II I / II. 2.9.

,, I IV,,. 2.1.2,..,.

.

.

.,,.,.

2.2.1, -. (.,, [105, 122]),.. 2.2,.

1).

,.

, .

(,,, ),.,,.,,,,,.., (,, ).

2).,,, -.

,, (,..),,,,.,...,,,,,..,.,,, (, ), ?

,,. 2.2,,,,,.

,.,

.

, /.,.,,,..,. [48]...., (. 2.1.1,,,, ).

(..) ( , ).

, (,, ),,.

,,,,. [81].

,, (.. )

,,,,.,, XX ,. [105]...

.,, ( ).

,...

,,,

, ( )., ,.

, : ( ),,.,. [45]:

, - (, -..), 1970-.,.

: .( ) ..

,,, -. ,..

,,,. [15]., ( ).,.

-,,.

...

, . :

, (, ). -, ,,.

,.. IV,,. 2.1.2.. 2.2.,, ( ).,, ( ),,.

,,., IV,.,. 2.2.1,,..,,,.

, IV. ,. [3].,,,., -,,, .

-,,,.,,,,.

?,.

,,,,,,, .

,,, : , ,.

( ).

,,.

(, ), -,.

( ),. 2.2.

..,, (.. 1.1),..,,,,,.

(.. 1.1),..

,,.., ;

, -, ( ).,,. (,, ).

,,,,,. 2.2.1,.

,. (.. 1.1) , ,,.

,. [20, 129].

, ,,.

.,,,,,, ,.

,, .,, ( ).

, (, ), ,,,..

,,.,,,.

,,,.

,,. ., -,,.,,,,.

,.. ,,,.. (,, ) , :

., -.

(.. ) [76].

,,,,.,,,. -,,,..

-,,.,, (, ),.,,,,, ;

, ,.,, , ,.

2.3.2. :

?

,,,,,., (.. ),, ,, , ..,,,,.,,,. . (.., ).

,, .

,, ,.,.

2.1.1, ,.

.,..

[8], (.. ).

( ) :.

,,,..

?,.

, (,..),,.

,, (.,, [32]), ,.. ( )., ,..,.,, [14].,,.

..

[30],,.

, -,, (, :

. -,,, -,,,., ;

..

, ( ),,,,,,,.,..

.

[8].

,,,..,,,.,.

, ,,.

[68]:

, (, ).,.., ;

, ,.

, ., ,,,, (.. )... .

,,.,,.

.,...

.

(. [86]., ,..,, ).,, ( )., .

. 2.3.1.. .

, .

,,, ?,.

,, (..

).

.

,,, . ,. :,, 10-15 (, ),,,, 1 (. ), , (,, ).

(..

).

,.

( ),,,,..

,, (, )?

,, ?

.

[86],, : ( ).,,,

,.,.

2.3.3. ,. 2.1.1,,,,., (,. 2.3.2), ( ). , .,... (frugal1 innovations):,.

,.

, , , ..

,.

., 65.

2...

General Electric (GE)..

.

,., $ 800, $, - $1.

,. GE

,,.

Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), ( )., $4.

. -, ,.. IV,. 2.1.2,,. 2.2.1, -. -, (,,,. [96]) ,,,.

:

.

VIP,,

. .

, - ., Nokia ( ), ( ), ( ). VNL [56].

,,,.,, I.,.

,..,. 2.9.

,,,.

, ( ).

,, ( !)1,,,.

,,, ,., ,,,,,,

. (.

),,.

,.

, . -,,,, ,.

[47].

,

,

,.,., ( ),,.

:,...

,.. ,..,,,. .,, ( )., (..

).

, , ( ).

,,,,,.,,, ,.,,,,.,,.,,,,,,, (,,..) .... 2.1.1,,,,. -. .,...

, [53].

1.

, -.

,.., .

,,,.

2., ( ), ,,..

,.

,.

,..,, ( , ) /,.

3.,,,..

., /,...

, -.

, ,,,,.

4.

,.

,.,,.

5..

,,.,, -,...

3.

, -.,,,.,,..

-,, , .

3.1., 3.1.1.

,,, , ..

,

,, ( ).,,,. [81].

,,,. [7, 56, 81]., ,.

,,,,.,..,,.

, ( ) (.. 2.1.1).,.. -.

,,,,, ( )., . (,,..,..), ( ).

, ( ),.

.

1.

,,,,,, (.. ),,,,,. [46].

.. ,. 3.13.

,.,,,.,,, ( ).,,,, , -,.

( ).. [38], [39].

,,,.

: -..

. 3.1

, (,.),,,.

.

(frugal innovations),.

2.3.3..,, .,

,.

, (.,, [31]),

.

,, (, ),.,, .

,,

,.

, .

,.

(.,, [99]): ,,.,,,,, ( ). , .

,,.

, - (..,,. ).,,.,,,.

3.1.2.

N.

. n ( ), i = 1,...n (, N )., n {M i }, {i }.

., ,g g,,g g.

,, r. S S (r).,, :

pj = rgj +aj, j=, -,

;

aj - ( ) j,., a j Qj, 0,, Q j,..

,,

,.. p p.

,, ,,., ,,,,,, qmin :

i M i i M i qi = = qmin, rg +a p qi - .

,,

n,, :

qmin, qn qmin.

qn + ,, Nn qi.

Q= n i = n + n, ,, .,,

,.. qmin. i- :

i M i i M i qi = =.

rg +a p, ,, :

n N qiK.

QK = n i =, , ,..

qi ;

i n ;

i n.

qi : , ( )?,,, ,,.

,..,,, ..,, (.., ).

(.., ),..

, .

, , ,.

( ),,,.

, -,,.,, qsat,.,... qmin., (, qmin 0 ), : qsat qmin. qi qi.

,,, qsat = qmin.

qsat qmin.

, :

qmin ;

i n qi = 0;

i n 0;

i n K i M i qi = min qmin ;

r g + a ;

i n,,..

. 3.3.

, ( DK ) (D ) :

D = D + D = g Q + g Q.

r*, :

D ( r* ) = S ( r* ).

{a } j,,.

r {a }j {Q } j a j (Q j ), j =,.

{a } {Q }, j j r. .

r* r, D ( r* ) = S ( r* ).,.

,,,,. ,.

,, .,,

( ) n,

. .

3.1.3.

. N 140..,,. 2.1.

. 2.2.2 (, I 2007.,. [87]).

,,,,.

1%-.

2.3. 2.2.2.

,, 5%.,,, 12.

a j = 0, j =,, (.. Q j,, ), : S = Const = 1.. /.

,g , = g 100. /. =5. /..

,, a =../. =1../. (.. ). qmin 1. /.. :

0,7.. / ( ), 14.. / .

..,, .

. 3. (, ), ( ).

, 300../.. ( ), , 48,0-57,4.../.*., 11-97-, 2,4-44,0.

../.*.

.

./.

, 0 0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5,../. 3.2. ( ) .

, ,,,, .,,,,.

, . ,.

,,., 5% (..

96-100- ).

-, ..

3.3 (,, ).

.

./.

, 5% 0 0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5,../. 3.3 ( ),,, 1060../.,..

.

,

.

4%,, ( 53 %).. 3., ,, 5.

, 50%.

(" " ) 1,.* 0,./, 0, 0, 0, 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 5%. 3.4. ( ) ,,,,. [57]...

,..,,,.

,

,, ,.

:,.. (,..).

, ,.

, ,., . ,.., .,, .., ,,, (. [29, 48, 127]). ,.

3.1.4.

,,.

, : ,.., ?

,, ?

.

, ,,.,,,...,, (.,, [31]),..,., ( ).,,,...

(tragedy of commons), (..,,, ,,.,, [31]).

..,. [103].

..,.

,.

.,, ,,.

,,, ., -,.

:

,.. ?,. 2.3,..

.

,,. 3.2,,..,.

,,,.

(, ).,,, ,.,, 200../.,

7 (94-100- ),,, 34,3.../.*.

, ( 7% ,, ) , 87% (11-97- ),, (98-100- )., 3% 40%.

,, 5%,,.

,

,,, (, ), .,, .. 3.,, 930../.. ( 100- 37% ).. 3.6,. 3.4, .

.

./.

, 800 0 0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5,../. 3.5. ( ) 1,.* 0,./, 0, 0, 0, 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90. 3.6. ( ), , ( ), .

,,.

1), .

,,,.,., ,.,

,, ,,..

. -.

2) .

, ,,.

, .

, ( ) ( ).,,,,.

,., , (.. ).

(..

) .,, .

,,, .

[104], ,,,., -, :,,,.,,.

,. ,,.

, -,,, .

?

,, {a } j, {M i }. ,,,,.

,,, , , .

,,, ,., .,, ,,.

,,.

,., -,,,.. (.),, , , ,,,.

,,,,,,., ( ).,,.

(,, , ), : ..

.

, ( !)., ( ),,,...

(. [23]):

,,,, - (, ),.,..

( ),. ,.

, ,,,.,, , .

,

., , ,,,, ,.

,.

,, : -, - (,

).

. [69],,.

,.,.

,.,.. ., :

, - ?,,, ?.., ?,,,.. ? ?,,, :.

., ( ),. 2.3.2., , ( ) ,, ?..,,,,,.,.

,,,,,,.

,. - .

3.2.

:

1) ( ), 2),.

( ), ., ,.

, -,.,,.

,.,,,..

.

.

,,.

, ,,. (, ) (, ),. (.), , .

3.2.1. :

.. [9].

.,,,.

,,, p, q = q A + q B., :

p ( q ) = a b q, a = p ( 0) ;

b, ( a = ).

q p = b,.,,, (,, )..,,,. :

gi (, -, i = A, B ;

i - ) p ;

i ( i ), i = A, B.

, i = A, B, i- :

i i gi ;

= +p,,.

, ( ), (.,, [31]).

, , :

a + c j 2ci i q* =, i, j = A, B ;

3b :

2a c A c B a + c A + c B p* = a b q* = a b =. (3.1) 3b ,, :

(a + c 2c i ) j i =, (3.2) * 9b,j i-.

,, :

a + c j 2c i = a + ( c j c i ) c i.

., i i 0) j (, *. :

j (a c ) j =. (3.3) 4b a cj,, j-,.

(3.2).

ci,, (c c ).

j i, ?

, (a b),.

i- (a + c 2c i ).

j :

g j 2( gi ).

a + c j 2c i = a + j i +p +p,,.,, (, ).

i g.

p,,,,....

,, ,.

,,.,,.,,,,..,,,, -.

, (3.2):

( g j 2g i ).

a + c j 2c i = a + j i 2 +p (3.4), i-.,. (3.4), j g gi 2g i g j,,.. i-,,,.

, gj ( gi ).,,,,...

-,. [4].

,,.

,,,... , !

.,,,,,,. QWERTY [5].

, ( ), ( ).

,,,,,.,, .

,, .,.,.

, rg i, i 1% rp.

1% ( g j 2 g i ) p 1% 1%, 1% ( ):

( g j 2g i ) gi 2 g i 2g i % 1%, =j =i g i g j 2g i g 2g i 2g g j gj gi -,, i-.

gj, gi, rp rg i...,.

:

rg i 2gi, (3.5) 2gi g j rp rg i gi.

( ) j g 2 rg i rp gi, gj 1 -, (3.4)...., ,.

gi, 1, gj..

,,,.

,, ,.

rg i 2,..

rp 1%,,.

., 1%,,.,,,.,..

S 3.7 (. 1.17 ).

. 3.7.,,,,,.

rg i rp.

, (3.1),,.

, .

i-, (3.3), (p gi ).

, 1%, ., rg i,, rp. , (3.5),,,,,.

:

,,,.

.

,,.

.

,., (. (3.1)):

( gi + g j ) i j a + c i + c j a + c + c + p (3.6) p* = = 3 ,.

i 1%, :

( 0,99 g i + g j ) a + c i + c j + p, p* = 1% :

( gi + g j ) a + ci + c j + 0,99 p.

p* =,,,, 1%.

: i,, i j g g,., j.

,, ( ) -.,. 2.2,,.

.

,,. 2.2.1 2.2.2:

,,...,,,,.. 2.2.3-2.2.4.

( ).

.

,.

( = 0,07;

b = 10-13.

) :

(.-.) (./..).. 3.1, ( ).

3. ( ),./.-. 0,015 0,,./.-. 0,01 0, g, /.-. 20, ,. [31].

,,, A B,.

. 3.8 (3.2, 3.3) (./ ) (, ).,,.

( ), (3.6).

: ( ),.

, (,, )...

(,.,, [33, 46]),,.

3,0 0, 0, 2, 0,./ 2,0 ' ' / 0, 1,,, 0, ' 1, 0, 0, 0, 0,0 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800,./. 3.8.

( ) :

, ;

, ;

p, p .

( gA = 15 / ).-.,.. 25% (,,, [110]),.

. 3.8, ( ).

.,, :,.

. 35.

( 15 ),.-.2.-.

,.,, ( 1%- ),,.,,./, 57%, ,.. 300./ 18%,.. 3.8.

,,, .

.

, (. 3.8).

, 900./ 40%,, 3,3%...

.

, .,,, ( ),.

.,,,.

, (, )., , (, ).

3.2.2.,, ( ),,,..,,., 2009.,,.,,,.,..,,.

,,..,..,.... [26].

.

, . -,.

, ,.

-, (,, ),.

[26], ,, .

,,,.., ,,.

,, ,.

,,.,,,,,,,..., ?.,.

,,,,,,,.

,,, (,,,..),.,.,.

(.,, [0]),,,,,,.

,.

.

( ), ., (..,,..),, ,..

,.

[93], (, ). -,.,,,.,,,.,, ,,...., ,,.,.,.

[46],, ( ),, ( ).

:,.,,,.

:,.

,,,.,,

.

,..,, .

, . ?

-,,, : ( ).

,,. ,,.,,.,, :

.

.

,.

),,.,, (,..

rp rg i ),,.

,.,, rg g ( ) ( ) g rp 2 rg.

, (.. ),.

) rg i.

,.., , rg 2g,, g 2g rp,

.,,.

(, ), (.. g g ).,,., ,, ( )., .

.,, (.. ).

, , ( ),., [9],,,,,.

, -,,,.

.,.,, 27 2009..

, [113].,,,.

),,,,... .

,,,,., ,, ;

,,,.

,,, (..

, )., [95, 85].

,.., (, )

., (.. ),..., (),, , -.

3.3.

3.3.1.

,.,,,.

,,,.,,,,,,..,,.

(, 2),., :,,., .

.,.

,,,,,.,. :,.

,,,,. [111] [112],,, 1991 1995.

,,,.,, [120] [95].

,..

.

(, 2,. [79]),.,,.

. [123],.,,, ( ) .

, ,. :,,,.

, (..

)?,,,,,,.,,, [31, 43],,..., , .

.,,,.

, ?

. 13% 2-3% 2,, (.

[22])..

,,,,..

,,.

3.3.2., . [31, 41, 44].

.. [42].

. :,,.

.,, ,, -. [31, 43],, :

= a, (3.7),,, ;

a -,,. :

,,,.

.,,, ( ), ( ),,,.,. [46]:

= + g*, (3.8) - (.., ;

g ), ;

-.

, (, ), (, ), ,,,, ,, - (. [54]).

,,,,,,.,.

,,,,,.... 1 1...,,..., g.

G.

(,..),, (,..).

.,,, ( 2)., ( ) :

= g*, (3.9) ,.

3,125 2/...,. [10].,,.,.,,.,, (,,,..),, (, ).

, :

. (3.10) = G* G g,,,

., ( ).,,,,..

.

, (. [78]), .

,.

,, (, ).,,,,. [10, 69].,,.

,, ?

(3.7), :

,.

, (3.7) ( , )., :

G g g. (3.11).., 1,,,.,.

2.

, :

X. (3.12),.,. 2.2.,,, (,..),,,.,,,.,.. 2.2.2.,,,,.

3.3.3., (3.12), (3.11).

,.., (3.7)?,, :

GG,,.

gg,,, :

( - -, ),,.., :

= *G +, (3.13) , ;

,.

(3.7) :

=, (3.14)..,.. :

+ *G = ;

=( ) + (g )* g,, - ,,.

,,., [92], *G 1-2%,...

,,,,...., :

g*, (g )* g.

, (3.13),, :

G *(g ), g * (, ), G g g.

(3.11),,., (3.13),,., (3.7), (3.11),,,...,.

, (3.11),, :

G =g g (3.15)., (, ), ( ).

(3.15), :

G *(g ).

g *,, *G = X, *g =. :

X,.. (3.12).,, (3.15),,., (3.11), (3.12),,,...,.

,, ( ),,.,,,.

,. ? 2,,.

( ), ( ), (NOX),..,,,..

.

[31, 69],.,,,,,.

[31],,, ( 20 ).

,, -,.

,.

( 2, ).,, (NOx),.. (, Euro 1 Euro 6).

,..

.,.,, ,.,,,,, ,..

.

, (,, ).

3.3.4.,,

,,., -,.

,,,

,.. (3.11) (3.12), ,.. (3.7).

,.,,,.,,.

,,,.

,,.,, (.., 2) S, , , (,, )... .

,, ,.

,..

(,, ).

( ).

,. 2.2.

.

,..,.,, [19].,, (3.11) (3.12),,,.,.

,, (, ), ( )., -,.

.,. ,, .

1.,.

-,, , ,.

, ( ),,.

2., - .

.

3.,,,., ,.,.

4.,,.,,,.

,,,.

5.,,, (..

, ).

( ), ( ) ( ).

6.,, .,,.

.

(, ),,, .,, ( ).

4.

4.1.

,, ,.

,,,.,,,,. [44].,,.,.

,..

[42],.

,.,.

.

., (3.12) :

( ) a, (4.1) ( ) ., (3.7),,...,.. 4.2.,.

, (.. ),.

,,,.

4.1.1.

, :

) (, ) t, :

,. 3.3.

( ) =t+ ;

(4.2) ) [, ] s, :

( ) =( ) +(g ) *( + s ) ;

(4.3) g ) :

( ) =( ) +(g ) *( * ) (4.4) g +.,.. [80] .

,,.

(4.3) (4.4), (, ).

(4.2-4.4),,, (.. (4.1)):

( ) =a ( ) (g )* (4.5) tmin = a g ( ) * a smin = ;

(4.6) g g s 1 ( ) * a min. (4.7) min = = * ( g ) g.,, 2,5.,, :

= 2,0 /.. (., g = 75000.., P., = T ).

,, .

. (3.14), 1600./ :

= (g )* * = g, 60..

./.

* = = = (g )* 0,5 /..*75000..

g,.,. :

= 12000...,, G :

2/..., (3.12) = = 3, :

12000...

G 2 = 3, * * =0,5... 75000....

,, -,.. [42].

*(g ) = 3,125.

2 g *0,5 /..=1,.....

1,.

,,.,,,.

,, ?,,,.

2.,,,.

,,.,,.

,.

(4.6-4.7),,, 1000./.

, (. (4.5)) (g )* tmin = a g = 60..

= -0,5 /..*1000./ =300./..

75000..

,, *,.. (.

(4.6)):

* smin = = 1600./ -1000./ =600./.

2, ( (4.7)) 600./..

smin min = = = 3,125...

,,.

, (4.6), (4.7).

(..

),..

.

min = 6,25 CO =.. 192. / CO2 = 1200./..

min = 7,8125 CO =.. 192./ CO2 = 1500./..

(, ).

300./..

1200./.., (./..), (800./..)., 60%. ( ) ( ).

,,,,.,,,.,,,.

[71].

,, ,, (,,,,, (.., ).

,, ?

,., (4.6) (4.7),, :

( ) (g )= g a min = (g ) g ( )= a tmin =. (4.8) (g ) (g g ) g, (, (4.7)):

tmin g g min = =g = tmin (4.9) ( ) g g g g,, :, , ) [69].

,,, :

g tmin, g g,..g.

g. ., 2,,,..

.,,.

,, S-,. 1.17 3.7.

,.

.,, S :

, g g,..g tmin.

g g. 4.1.

9 8.

7../ 6, 5 4 000 t t 3 2 1 0 500 1 000 1 500 2 000 2 500 3,./. 4.1.

( 1) ( ;

1000./..):

( , ).

,,.

, 1600./ ;

(, ),,.,, 1600./,, 5000./..,.., 1600./ ;

( ),,.,, 1600./,, ;

( ),.,,, (,, 1000./ 4100./..

5000./..),, , 1 /..(,, ).. 4.2.

3 3.

. 2./, 2 t 1 t 1 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1,./. 4.2.

( 2),, (3.7).

.

( , ),

,,

(, ).,,, S

,,,

.

4.1.2.

, S,,,,. ,, ., , ,,,,..

.,,.

,.

,, ( ), ( ) (.. ).

, tmin 1:

= + tmin, t min :

g = + = + tmin.

g g, :

g tmin tmin,, t g g g g g,..g.

g,,,,,,,.,. 3.3, ,, g.

,g,,,..

.. [40].

., -,.

.,,. ;

,.

p 1.

,, = +t., t, :

(1 p ) ;

p t, = +t.

t, ( ) + t + (1 p ) = p = + p t. (4.10) (. (4.5)), tmin = ( ),...

t,,., :

+ p t +t,..

, t tmin =. (4.11),,,.,, ( ),. ?,.

,, :

= + p t g ( ).

= + = + g g, ( ):

g tmax =, (4.12) g p g, tmin = (,. (4.11)).

( t min ;

tmax ) g p.

,, g g,, ( ):

g =.

g,,,., g (g ), , ,.

,,..

( p 1 ),,., , , ,, -,.

(,, ),.

4.1.3.

, ., S,,.

,,. ( ) (.

[34]),,,.

.

, (,..) ( ),

, ., min,,.

.

, .

, (14-16) ;

,,.

, ( ).

,,,.

,, - (, ),, ,.

?


,, ?,,,, ....,,,.,., ( ),.

,,.

1),,,,.

.,, ,,., .

2),. ( S ) ( ), ,...,,.,,,.

,.

,.., (. [35]).

, (, ).

, .,,, [69], ,, ,..

,, (,..).

3),..,, S (.. 1.17).,,,,,, [54].

.

,....

, ,.,,.

,,,,.,,.,,, ( (4.6-4.7), , ).

4).,..,, ?..

.,, (,, - ).

-. (. [85]),,.

,. [13]..,,,,,,.

(,, 2011.

2025.),.

,,, ,, .,. 3.3, (..

),.,.

,,. [112].,,,,.

,, ,..,, (.,, [35, 54]).,,,,,.

4.2.

4.2.

90 .,,.,,,,,,.

, (.

. 4.1,. [101, 108]).

4.1.

,, / 13, 10, 18,,, 100 ( 30%,, 10%, -, ( Production Tax Credit, PTC).,.,..

[51], (PTC) (Investment Tax Credit, ITC),, ( \ ), ITC ( ).

, ITC.

Oak Ridge National Laboratory ( ), 10- 1,5 / 25%.

,,.,,. 4.2 ( [108]).

4. 0,69,,, 0,181.

, 100%,,,.

,, /,.

.,,. 4.3 ( [108]).

4., 36% 5,,,, 100% 100% -,,,,,,,, ( ),.

,,,.,. 4. ( [108]).

4., 17,5% 5% 19% 7% 20%, 10%,, 22%, 5%,,,,,.,,,.

,,..

,,.,, ( ).

,,. 4.5 ( [108]).

4., -, - 25%,, 75%, 10% -, 30% 15%, - 100% 100%,., .

,,.

.

.

.

,,.,.. 4.6 ( [108]).

4. 28% 100% 20 30.,,, 15,,.

,., (NPV).,.,,,. NPV,..

4.7 ( [108]).,,.

4. 10% 60% 25%.,.

-, -.

.

1997 ( ),,,,,,,,.. 4.8 ( [108]). 1997.,,,, ( ).

4., 1997.

, 0,21 1,42/ 0,34 /(.), 0,15 /( ), 1,17 ( ),,, 16 1, 25%, VAT 0.06125/,, 0.55/kWh 0.0639/kWh (, ) 6.8/ 0.029/kWh (, ) : 5.084/, :1.286/ 18.59/ NOK 104/ 16.54 56.80/ 42.52 80.54/ CZK 472/ 36.5 re/ CHF 210/,, -,,,, [63].

, .,,,.,,,,,,.

4.2.2. ( ),,,,.,.

,,, [51].

,., (.

4.3).,.

. 4.3..,,,,.

-.

., (. 4.4).

.4.4.,,,,,, ,.

,,.

, .,,,, (,,, ),.

4.2.3.

,,., (, ), .

2012 (EnEV) 35 / 1...

, EnEV (. 4.5),. [116].

. 4.5.

1.

,.. -.

.,, ( ). ( ),,. 20% (, ).

,, Renewable Energy Sources Act.

, 20- Renewable Energy Sources Act 9,20 5,02 /, 1 2010. 0,5 /. 1%.

., 15 / 12, 3,5.,. 5%, 2015. 20,.

,,,.

.,,,.. GE, Vestas Suzlon.

,, [117].

.,,., ( ).

. cash-flow.

: ( ), ( ) ( ).,,,,, ( ). KfW, [117, 118].

,,,.,,.

,,.,,.,,,,.,.

.

,,.

4.6.

. 4.6.,,.. (. [16]).,,.

4.6,,, ( 2000-.).

,, , ,..

1.,,., (. 4.7).

10%, 25%,.

2%, 5% 8% [117, 118].

. 4.7. 2000-.(, ),,.,.

2.,.

.

,, (Renewable Energy Law, REL) 30%- 2020 ( ).

,.

3., (Renewable Energy Sources Act).

4.

., 2009,.,,,,.

,,,.

,,,,.

,,,, [117].

, -.

5.,,,. (Renewable Energy Sources Act) (Independent Power Producers, IPP).

,.

,,,,., [117, 118].

(. 4.8),.

.4.8.

-,

.

4.3.

,. ,.

, (,..),,,,,.

,.,,.,,,,,.

.,,, [51].

.

,., 2008 [97], 12, 10,6 4 [51].

,,.

,,., ( - ),.

,,, : 1) ;

2) ;

3) ;

4).

,,,, - (. 4.9).

. 4.9.

, .

,,, (.. 4.9).

4. - / / - / / - - / - 2 - / -, -, - / ;

, -,..

/ - - - / - / - / - - / - / - / -.

, / / -. / - / / -, - - / -,,,,,,.,,, -,,,,,,,.

. 261 : ,,,,,, ., 261,,,, -.,,,.

,,.

:

. (, ).

. (Btus) - ( - /../ ).

.,.

. -,.

.

,,, ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager.

.

,, ASHRAE Standard 90 Title 24.

-,,,,.

/.,,,., -,,.,.

,, , -

I 2011,,.

.

, I ( 7.4.

),., -2014..

( 6.8. ) ( 6.2. ).,,.

71 ( 3 ) 23 ,.,,,.

. 65-70%,.,,, smart grids..,, (. 4.10),,,,,,.

. 4.10.

( : ),,,, (. 4.10),, (,, ( ) ).

,, ++,, +.

4., - ++ ++ ++ ++ + ++ + ++ ++ + ++ ++ ++ + ++ ( ) ++ ++ + ++ + ++ ++ + + ++ + ( ) - ++ + ++ ++ + ++ + + + ++ + + ++ + + ++ ++ + + ++ + +,,,,,,, [51].,.

,,,,..

..

,,,,, .

,,,,,,.,,, (, ).

[97],,,, (,,,..).

,,,,,.

(. 4.11),,,,.

,.

4.1.,,,,.

. 4.11.. 2- ( ),,,, [51].,,, ,,,, [63].

,,,.

,,,.,,,,,.

,,,.

, - (.. 4.12,. [73]),,,.

,, ,,..

,,..

.

. 4.12.,,,,,,.

,,,.,,,,,,,,.

.

1., (, ), (, ).,,,.

,,.

2. ( ) ( ).,, (, ).

.

,,,,.

,,,,,., .

,.

-..,., (..

).

( ).

,,.

,, .,.,,...

, .

,,..

,,., :, .

,,,,.,,,,,,.

,,

.

,.

-, .

,,.

, :

, ,,, ;

, ,.

1. 2011 Annual Statistical Report on the contribution of Bio mass to the Energy System in the EU-27 / Brussels: AEBIOM, June 2011. 101 p.

2...,..

//. 2009. ( ).

3. //.

,, 17 2008.

http://www.scepsis.ru/library/id_2042.html.. 4.

/.:, 2000 32.

5...

: //, 2, 2012,. 48-63.

6. //, 9, 2007.

.

7. //,.

08.08.2012. :

http://www.vz.ru/politics/2012/8/8/592414.print.html 8...,..

// : ..:

, 2009.. 292-298.

9..,..

: //. 2010.. 2, 3.. 22-31.

10...,..

// :. 2012. 3.. 52-63.

11...,..

//. 2012. 1.. 78-100.

12...,..,..,..

/.:, 1992.

13.

//, 29.07.2011.

: http://www.vz.ru/news/2011/7/29/511108.html, 14...

/.: -, 2002 352.

15..

: //, 09.07.2012.

16...

:..:, 2006, - 396.

17...

// - 2009,.:, 2009, c. 36-41.

18.,.

/:, 1980 390.

19...,..

//, 3, 2008,. 98-109.

// 20..,.

, 9, 2011,. 26-33.

/.:, 2006 208.

21..

22...,..

//, 2, 2003,.

15-17.

23...,..,..,..

. /.:, 2001, 224.

24. //,.

13.08.2012. :

http://vz.ru/economy/2012/8/13/593207.html 25....

. /.:,, 1997 128.

26...,..,..

// , 06.04.2010,,.

27...

( )/.: -, 2009 .

28....

, 250-., 1975. //. 1976. 1.. 34-43.

29. :..

/.:

, 2008 128.

30. :,.

...... /.:

, 2000 608.

31..,.

, //, 6, 2005.

32... CALS- : - /.:

, 2008, 124.

33...

/.:, 2009 280.

34...

/.:, 2011 278.

35. : /..

.: -, 2012 684.

36...

// :. 2011. 1.. 19-23.

37...,..

//.

. 2009. 5.. 86-97.

38...,..

// :.

2012. 23 (164).. 2-12.

39... .., : // :. 2012. 40 (295).. 27 39.

40...,..,..

// :. 2012. 33 (288).. 16-26.

41...,..

//, 3, 2007,. 39-45.

42...,..

//, 2, 2009,. 23-40.

43...,..,..

//, 11, 2008,. 65-70.

44...,..,..

//, 3, 2007,. 61-70.

45...,..,..

. -.

,,..2 /.: URSS, 2007.

224.

46...

/.: , 2002. 304.

47. //,.

05.08.2011. :

http://www.odnako.org/blogs/show_12253/ 48.,.

//, 17.07.2006. :

http://www.scepsis.ru/library/id_735.html 49...

// Terra Economicus, 2009,. 7, 1,. 2,. 48-52.

50. // , 11.06.2010.

51../..-....:, 2009, 160.

52...

// :

. 5 (260), 2012.. 9-15.

53.. // -, 24.08.2010. :

http://scolcovonet.ru/inno/nemeckii-uchenyi-mensh-/ 54. /.:

..

, 2011 88.

55. :..

//, 3, 2009,. 33-43.

56. :

.

// , 22.03.2010. :

http://eco.ria.ru/documents/20100322/215718166.html 57. 10. ?

.

//, 12.12.2011. :

http://scepsis.ru/library/id_3097.html 58. 2010. 2050. Russian Translation. / Paris, France, International Energy Agency, 2010.

59. ..

//, 2012, 1,.24-33.

60. /.:

..

-..:

, 2003,. 506-508.

61. :..

.( - )/.... .: , 2011, 352.

62. /..

,, 2002 98.

63...

// :, 43 (136), 2011,. 71-78.

64. -..

// :, 28, 2012,. 47-55.

65...,..

//, (488), 2012,. 21-27.

66...,..

( ) // :

, 2011, 46,. 4-8.

67. //..

- .

http://scepsis.ru/library/id_2101.html 68.,..

// - . http://scepsis.ru/library/id_2083.html 69...

/.:, 2009 331.

70...

//. 1.

2009.. 5-10.

71...

: //. 3. 2009.. 69-74.

72. / :,.

2005 797.

73...

//, 2010, 4,. 73-86.

74..,.

//, 2, 2003,.

18-19.

75. // ,.

08.07.2011.

76..,.,..,.

: /.:, 288.

77...,..

// :

. 41 (248). 2011.. 2-12.

78...

: //, 4, 2009,. 54-64.

79. -..

//, 5, 2004,. 86-101.

80. //..

, 4, 2007,. 74-83.

81. //, 18 (82),.

05.06.2011.

82...

/.:, 2010.

83...

:

/.:, 2012.

84...,..

// :, 2011, 34.

85...,..

//, 2011, 3.

86...

. /.:, 2012. 346.

87...,..,..

: //, 3, 2007,. 62-74.

88...

/.: WWF, 2010 .

.. 1.

89.

/.: -, 2005 1302.

90. A National Offshore Wind Strategy: Creating an Offshore Wind Energy Industry in United States / EERE Information Center, 2011, February. DOE/GO- 102011-9288.

91. Airbus A-340- // www.aviaport.ru, 13.10.2009.

92. Aircraft Engine and Engine Parts Manufacturing: 2002 / in:

2002 Economic Census. Manufacturing. Industry series. U.S. Census Bureau, 2004 47 p.

93. Antoci, A. and Bartolini, S. Negative externalities as the en gine of growth in an evolutionary context // MPRA Paper 13908, University Library of Munich, Germany, 1999.

94. Biomass Program: Biennial Review Report. An Independent Evaluation of Platform Activities for FY 2010 and FY 2011 / DOE.

Washington D.C., February 2012. 33 p.

95. Brnnlund, R. Environmental policy without costs? A review of the Porter hypothesis // S-WoPEc, Swedish Working Papers in Economics, Ume Economic Studies, 766, 2009 49.

96. Chiu, Y.-W., Walseth, B. and Suh, S. Water Embodied in Bi oethanol in the United States // Environmental Science and Technol ogy. 2009. Volume 43. No. 8. pp. 2688-2692.

97. Comparing Practices in R&D Tax Incentives Evaluation. By Expert Group on R&D Tax Incentives Evaluation. Final Report. / Brussels: European Commission. 2008.

98. Fargione, J., Hill, J., Tilman, D. et al. Land clearing and the biofuel carbon debt // Science. 2008. Vol. 319. pp. 12351238.

99. Frondel, M., Horbach, J. & Rennings, K. End-of-Pipe or Cleaner Production? An Empirical Comparison of Environmental Innovation Decisions Across OECD Countries // ZEW Discussion Papers 04-82. 2004.

100. Global Market Outlook for Photovoltaics until 2016 / Brussels: EPIA, 2012. 76 p.

101. Goodward J., Gonzale M. Renewable Energy Tax Credits // The Bottom Line on, Issue 18, http://pdf.wri.org/bottom_line_renewable_energy_tax_credits_10 2010.pdf 102. Groom, M.J., Gray, E.M. and Townsend, P.A. Biofu els and biodiversity: Principles for creating better policies for biofuel production // Conservation Biology. 2008 Volume 22, Issue 3, pp.

602609, June 2008.

103. Hardin, G. The tragedy of the commons // Science, 162 (1968), pp. 1243-1248.

104. Heller, M. The tragedy of the anticommons: property in the transition from Marx to markets // William Davidson Institute of the University of Michigan business school, Working papers, se ries 40, 1997.

105. Herring, H.. 2008. Rebound effect // in: Encyclo pedia of Earth. Eds. Cutler J. Cleveland (Washington, D.C.: Envi ronmental Information Coalition, National Council for Science and the Environment). Web- :

http://www.eoearth.org/article/Rebound_effect 106. Howarth, R. Energy Efficiency and Economic Growth. Contemporary Economic Policy // 1997. Vol. XV, pp. 1-9.

107. Hueting, R. New scarcity and economic growth:

More welfare through less production? / Ph.D. thesis. University of Groningen. 1974.

108. International Tax Incentives for Renewable Energy:

Lessons for Public Policy / San Francisco, California, Center for Re source Solutions, 2005, 27 p.

109. Murphy, David J. and Hall, Charles A.S. Year in re viewEROI or energy return on (energy) invested // Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. Vol.1185, Ecological Economics Reviews p. 102118, January 2010.

110. National Plan for Aeronautics Research and Devel opment and Related Infrastructure / www.nasa.gov, December 2007 56 p.

111. Porter M.E. Americas Green Strategy // Scientific American. 1991. Vol. 264, 4, 96.

112. Porter M.E., Van den Linden C. Toward a New Con ception of the Environment-Competitiveness Relationship // Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9, 4, 1995.

113. Remarks by The President at the National Academy of Sciences Annual Meeting. National Academy of Sciences, Wash ington, D.C. 27 April 2009 // Web- :

http://www.whitehouse.gov/the_press_office/Remarks-by-the President-at-the-National-Academy-of-Sciences-Annual-Meeting/ 114. Saunders, H. The Khazzoom-Brookes Postulate and Neoclassical Growth // Energy Journal. 1992. No. 13, pp. 131-148.

115. Steinfeld, H. and Gerber, P. Livestock production and the global environment: Consume less or produce better? // Pro ceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2010;

107:18237 116. The German Heating and Cooling Industry. Industry Overview // Berlin, Germany Trade&Invest, 2009, pp. 12.

117. The Wind Energy Industry in Germany. Issue 2010/2011 // Berlin, Germany Trade&Invest, 2010, 16 pp.

118. The Wind Industry in Germany Economic report / Berlin, VDMA Power Systems German Wind Energy Association, 2010, 43 pp.

119. Vikstrm, P. Energy efficiency and Energy Demand:

A Historical CGE Investigation on the Rebound Effect in the Swed ish Economy 1957 / Ume University. Umea, Sweden, 2004.

120. Wagner, M. The Porter Hypothesis Revisited. A Lit erature Review of Theoretical Model and Empirical Test / Lneburg:

Centre for Sustainability Management, 2003, 46 p.

121. Wind Technologies Market Report, 2010 / EERE In formation Center, 2011, June. DOE/GO-102011-332.

122. Wirl, F. The Economics of Conservation Programs / Kluwer Academic, 1997.

123. Xepapadeas, A. & de Zeeuw, A. Environmental Pol icy and Competitiveness: The Porter Hypothesis and the Composi tion of Capital // Journal of Environmental Economics and Manage ment, 1999, vol. 37(2), pp. 165-182.

124. Yanarella, E.J., Levine, R.S. and Lancaster, R.W.

Research and Solutions: "Green" vs. Sustainability: From Semantics to Enlightenment // Sustainability: The Journal of Record. October 2009, 2(5), pp. 296-302.

125. http://www.altenergymag.com 126. http://www.bsh.de 127. www.clubofrome.org 128. http://www.epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu 129. http://www.ecs.umass.edu/biofuels 130. http://www.esha.be 131. http://www.geothermal-energy.org 132. www.gks.ru 133. http://thesolarfoundation.org 134. http://www.wind-industry germany.com/en/facts/growth-sector-wind-industry 135. http://www.wind-energie.de :

:

http://www.ipu.ru - (CD-R), 3, 17.12.. 0321301152

...

117997,.,.,

 
 >>  ()





 
<<     |    
2013 www.libed.ru - -

, .
, , , , 1-2 .